Section B
Directions: In this section, you are going to read a passage with ten statements attached to it. Each statement contains
information given in one of the paragraphs. Identify the paragraph from which the information is derived. You may choose a
paragraph more than once. Each paragraph is marked with a letter. Answer the questions by marking the corresponding
letter on Answer Sheet 2.
Apple’s Stance Highlights a More Confrontational Teach Industry
A) The battle between Apple and law enforcement officials over unlocking a terrorist’s smartphone is the culmination
of a slow turning of the tables between the technology industry and the United States government.
B) After revelations by the former National Security Agency contractor Edward J. Snowden in 2013 that the
government both cozied up to ( 讨好) certain tech companies and hacked into others to gain access to private data on an
enormous scale, tech giants began to recognize the United States government as a hostile actor. But if the confrontation has
crystallized in this latest battle, it may already be heading toward a predictable conclusion: In the long run, the tech
companies are destined to emerge victorious.
C) It may not seem that way at the moment. On the one side, you have the United States government’s mighty legal
and security apparatus fighting for data of the most sympathetic sort: the secrets buried in a dead mass murderer’s
phone. The action stems from a federal court order issued on Tuesday requiring Apple to help the Federal Bureau of
Investigation (F.B.I) to unlock an iPhone used by one of the two attackers who killed 14 people in San Bernardino,
California, in December.
D) In the other corner is the world’s most valuable company, whose chief executive, Timothy D. Cook, has said he will
appeal the court’s order. Apple argues that it is fighting to preserve a principle that most of us who are addicted to our
smartphones can defend: Weaken a single iPhone so that its contents can be viewed by the American government and you
risk weakening all iPhones for any government intruder, anywhere.
E) There will probably be months of legal tussling, and it is not at all clear which side will prevail in court, nor in the
battle for public opinion and legislative favor. Yet underlying all of this is a simple dynamic: Apple, Google, Facebook and
other companies hold most of the cards in this confrontation. They have our data, and their businesses depend on the global
public’s collective belief that they will do everything they can to protect that data.
F) Any crack in that front could be fatal for tech companies that must operate worldwide. If Apple is forced to open up
an iPhone for an American law enforcement investigation, what is to prevent it from doing so for a request from the Chinese
or the Iranians? If Apple is forced to write code that lets the F.B.I. get into the Phone 5c used by Syed Rizwan Farook, the
male attacker in the San Bernardino attack, who would be responsible if some hacker got hold of that code and broke into
its other devices?
G) Apple’s stance on these issues emerged post-Snowden, when the company started putting in place a series of
technologies that, by default, make use of encryption to limit access to people’s data. More than that, Apple - and, in
different ways, other tech companies, including Google, Facebook, Twitter and Microsoft - have made their opposition to
the government’s claims a point of corporate pride.
H) Appl’s emerging global brand is privacy; it has staked its corporate reputation, not to mention the investment of
considerable technical and financial resources, on limiting the sort of mass surveillance that was uncovered by Mr.
Snowden. So now, for many cases involving governmental intrusions into data, once-lonely privacy advocates find
themselves fighting alongside the most powerful company in the world.
I) “A comparison point is in the 1990s battles over encryption,” said Kurt Opsahl, general counsel of the Electronic
Frontier Foundation, a privacy watchdog group. “Then you had a few companies involved, but not one of the largest
companies in the world coming out with a lengthy and impassioned post, like we saw yesterday from Tim Cook. Its profile
has really been raised.”
J) Apple and other tech companies hold another ace: the technical means to keep making their devices more and more