
An intermediate phase induced by dilution in a correlated Dirac Fermi system
Lingyu Tian,1, 2 Jingyao Meng,1, 2 and Tianxing Ma1, ∗
1Department of Physics, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 100875, China
2Beijing Computational Science Research Center, Beijing 100193, China
Substituting magnetic ions with nonmagnetic ions is a new way to study dilution. Using determinant quantum
Monte Carlo calculations, we investigate an interacting Dirac fermion model with the on-site Coulomb repulsion
being randomly zero on a fraction xof sites. Based on conductivity, density of states and antiferromagnetic
structure factor, our results reveal a novel intermediate insulating phase induced by the competition between
dilution and repulsion. With increasing doping level of nonmagnetic ions, this nonmagnetic intermediate phase
is found to emerge from the zero-temperature quantum critical point separating a metallic and a Mott insulating
phase, whose robustness is proven over a wide range of interactions. Under the premise of strongly correlated
materials, we suggest that doping nonmagnetic ions can effectively convert the system back to the paramagnetic
metallic phase. This result not only agrees with experiments on the effect of dilution on magnetic order but
also provides a possible direction for studies focusing on the metal-insulator transition in honeycomb lattice like
materials.
I. INTRODUCTION
Since a number of exotic phenomena are observed in
graphene[1–3] and silicene[4–6], the honeycomb lattice has
become another topic that has received much theoretical[7,8]
and experimental[9,10] attention with respect to the square
lattice. In the absence of interactions, itinerant electrons on
a honeycomb lattice form a Dirac spectrum, and the den-
sity of state (DOS) near Fermi energy, E=0, vanishes lin-
early, which is in strong contrast with the square lattice whose
DOS diverges at E=0[11]. The difference is directly reflected
in the onset of long-range antiferromagnetic (AFM) corre-
lations at half filling: the AFM order can be exhibited in
the square lattice for arbitrarily small on-site Coulomb re-
pulsion U, whereas a finite value Uc∼4tis required in the
honeycomb lattice[12,13]. In addition, a transition from a
Dirac semimetal phase to an insulating phase is also found
at Uc[14,15]. The massless Dirac fermions have advanced
our understanding of physics beyond Landau’s theory of the
Fermi liquid[16,17], which states that interacting metallic
systems are similar to free Fermi systems.
In real materials, disorder is inevitably present and can be
controlled by doping. Disorder plays an important role in
many novel physical properties of modern science, touch-
ing upon topics from transport phase transition[18–20] and
superconductivity[21,22] to quantum spin liquids[23–26].
However, different types of disorder may have opposite in-
fluences on the physical mechanism under the same model,
which makes studies about disorder in correlated systems im-
portant and interesting. For example, the nearest-neighbor
hopping disorder is proven to enhance localization in the
two-dimensional repulsion Hubbard model under half fill-
ing, while the site disorder reduces this effect. Interestingly,
both types of disorder destroy the AFM order for dynamic
properties[27]. Another example is using strong-coupling per-
turbation theory to study the Anderson Hubbard model on
the honeycomb lattice, where an intermediate metallic state
∗txma@bnu.edu.cn
is present between the Anderson insulator and Mott insulator
under binary-alloy disorder but absent under uniformly dis-
tributed disorder[28,29].
Site dilution is the disorder achieved by substitution of
magnetic ions with nonmagnetic ions. It has been reported
that doping nonmagnetic Pt and G into GaFe4As3produces a
different modification of the electronic structure and transition
property[30]. In an insulating honeycomb magnet α−RuCl3,
replacing the magnetic ions Ru3+with nonmagnetic ions Ir3+
suppresses the magnetic order and induces a dilute quantum
spin liquid state in the low-temperature region [31–33]. Many
models have been used to reveal the phases in diluted systems
[34],and, motivated by cuprates such as La2CuxMg1−xO4, the
site diluted Hubbard model with on-site repulsion Ubeing
zero randomly on a fraction xof sites has been investigated in
two and quasi-two dimensions. On the strong coupling square
lattice, the AFM magnetic order at half filling disappears at
xc, which is consistent with the classical percolation thresh-
old x(perc,square)
c, while on the Lieb lattice, xcis almost twice
that of x(perc,lieb)
c[35]. This difference emphasizes the central
role of electron itinerancy in the magnetic response. In related
experiments, the honeycomb lattice provides a great platform
to study dilution. In CoTiO3, a linear relation between di-
lution and the critical temperature of magnetic transition is
observed over a wide dilution range[36]. Under out-of-plane
interactions or second- and third-nearest-neighbor exchange
interactions, the long-range AFM order survives well past the
classical percolation threshold xc=0.3[36–38]. Our study fo-
cuses on the magnetic phase transition caused by dilution in
the system with on-site interaction, and it is also interesting to
study whether magnetic order transition and metal-insulator
transition take place concomitantly.
Here, we use determinant quantum Monte Carlo (DQMC)
simulations to examine the effect of dilution on the ground
state properties of honeycomb lattices, including transport and
magnetic properties, of the half-filled case. Our key result
is that an intermediate gapped insulating phase without mag-
netic order is identified between the AFM Mott insulator and
the metal and is robust over a wide range of U, which is sum-
marized in the phase diagram in Fig. 1. The red dashed line
arXiv:2210.02662v1 [cond-mat.str-el] 6 Oct 2022