for northwest Europeans. I was of East European extraction myself and my kind
was being trampled into oblivion by a bunch of northwest Europeans. I was
therefore not intent on making Earthmen superior. The hero of the story was
from Rigel and Earthmen were definitely a bunch of second-raters.
Well, Campbell wouldn’t allow it. Earthmen had to be superior to all others,
no matter what. He forced me to make some changes and then made some himself,
and I was frustrated. On the one hand, I wanted to write my stories without
interference; on the other hand, I wanted to sell to Campbell. What to do?
I wrote a sequel to “Homo Sol”, a story called “The Imaginary”, in which only
the aliens appeared. No Earthmen. Campbell rejected it; it appeared in the
November 1942 issue of Superscience Stories.
Then inspiration struck. If I wrote human/alien stories, Campbell would not
let me be. If I wrote alien-only stories, Campbell would reject them. So why
not write human-only stories. I did. When I got around to making another
serious attempt at dealing with a Galactic society, I made it an all-human
Galaxy and Campbell had no objections at all. Mine was the first such Galaxy
in science fiction history, as far as I know, and it proved phenomenally
successful, for I wrote my Foundation (and related) novels on that basis.
The first such story was “Foundation” itself, which appeared in the May 1942
Astounding Science Fiction. Meanwhile, it had also occurred to me that I could
write robot stories for Campbell. I didn’t mind having Earthmen superior to
robots—at least just at first. The first robot story that Campbell took was
“Reason”, which appeared in the April 1941 Astounding Science Fiction. Those
stories, too, proved very popular, and presuming upon their popularity, I
gradually made my robots better and wiser and more decent than human beings
and Campbell continued to take them.
This continued even after Campbell’s death, and now I can’t think of a recent
robot story in which my robot isn’t far better than the human beings he must
deal with. I think of “Bicentennial Man”, “Robot Dreams”, “Too Bad” and, most
of all, I think of R. Daneel and R. Giskard in my robot novels.
But the decision I made in the heat of World War II and in my resentment of
Campbell’s assumption have stayed with me. My Galaxy is still all-human, and
my robots still meet only humans.
This doesn’t mean that (always assuming I live long enough) it’s not possible
I may violate this habit of mine in the future. The ending of my novel
Foundation and Earth makes it conceivable that in the sequel I may introduce
aliens and that R. Daneel will have to deal with them. That’s not a promise
because actually I haven’t the faintest idea of what’s going to happen in the
sequel, but it is at least conceivable that aliens may intrude on my close-
knit human societies.
(Naturally, I repel, with contempt, any suggestion that I don’t introduce
aliens into my stories because I “can’t handle them.” In fact, my chief reason
for writing my novel The Gods Themselves was to prove to anyone who felt he
needed the proof, that I could, too, handle aliens. No one can doubt that I
proved it, but I must admit that even in The Gods Themselves, the aliens and
the human beings didn’t actually meet face-to-face.)
But let’s move on. Suppose that one of my robots did encounter an alien
intelligence. What would happen?
Problems of this sort have occurred to me now and then but I never felt moved
to make one the basis of a story.
Consider— How would a robot define a human being in the light of the three
laws. The First Law, it seems to me, offers no difficulty: “A robot may not
injure a human being, or through inaction, allow a human being to come to
harm.”
Fine, there need be no caviling about the kind of a human being. It wouldn’t
matter whether they were male or female, short or tall, old or young, wise or
foolish. Anything that can define a human being biologically will suffice.