
Multi-sideband interference structures observed via high-order photon-induced
continuum-continuum transitions in argon
D Bharti1, H Srinivas1, F Shobeiry1, K R Hamilton2, R Moshammer1, T Pfeifer1, K Bartschat2, and A Harth1,3∗
1Max-Planck-Institute for Nuclear Physics, D-69117 Heidelberg, Germany
2Department of Physics and Astronomy, Drake University, Des Moines, IA 50311, USA and
3Department of Optics and Mechatronics, Hochschule Aalen, D-73430 Aalen, Germany
(Dated: January 24, 2023)
We report a joint experimental and theoretical study of a three-sideband (3-SB) modification of the
“reconstruction of attosecond beating by interference of two-photon transitions” (RABBIT) setup. The 3-SB
RABBIT scheme makes it possible to investigate phases resulting from interference between transitions of
different orders in the continuum. Furthermore, the strength of this method is its ability to focus on the
atomic phases only, independent of a chirp in the harmonics, by comparing the RABBIT phases extracted
from specific SB groups formed by two adjacent harmonics. We verify earlier predictions that the phases
and the corresponding time delays in the three SBs extracted from angle-integrated measurements become
similar with increasing photoelectron energy. A variation in the angle-dependence of the RABBIT phases in
the three SBs results from the distinct Wigner and continuum-continuum coupling phases associated with the
individual angular-momentum channels. A qualitative explanation of this dependence is attempted by invoking a
propensity rule. Comparison between the experimental data and predictions from an R-matrix (close-coupling)
with time dependence calculation shows qualitative agreement in most of the observed trends.
I. INTRODUCTION
The reconstruction of attosecond beating by interference of
two-photon transitions (RABBIT) is a widely employed tech-
nique to measure attosecond time delays in photoionization
processes [1–3]. The extraction of time information from
the RABBIT measurements usually involves retrieving atomic
phases encoded in the delay-dependent modulation of the
sideband (SB) yield. These SBs are traditionally formed
in the photoelectron spectrum by the interaction of two
photons (one pump, one probe) with the target. Spectral
harmonics from an attosecond pulse train (the pump photons)
form discrete photoelectron signal peaks. The presence of a
time-delayed infrared field (the probe photon) then creates
a signal in between these main peaks that oscillates with
the time delay. The so retrieved atomic phase (∆φat)
from the RABBIT measurement can be separated into a
single-photon ionization contribution (∆η, Wigner phase [4])
and a continuum-continuum (cc) coupling phase (∆φcc) by
applying an “asymptotic approximation” [5–7].
Variations of the RABBIT scheme, such as 0-SB, 1-SB, and
2-SB, have been utilized to study dipole transition phases and
attosecond pulse shaping [8–10]. As the name suggests, in
a 3-SB RABBIT scheme, three SBs are formed between two
consecutive main photoelectron peaks [11, 12]. The delay-
dependent oscillation in the photoelectron signal of these three
SBs requires more than one transition in the continuum, i.e.,
the absorption or emission of several probe photons. For a
hydrogenic system, we recently [12] extended the asymptotic
approximation to a decomposition scheme, which expands
the phase of the Nth-order dipole matrix element M(N),
describing the absorption of an ionizing extreme ultraviolet
(XUV) photon followed by N−1infrared (IR) photon
∗bharti@mpi-hd.mpg.de; Anne.Harth@hs-aalen.de
exchange in the continuum, into a sum of the Wigner phase
and N−1cc phases.
For atomic hydrogen, where numerical calculations with
high accuracy can be carried out by solving the time-
dependent Schr¨
odinger equation (TDSE) directly, we verified
that the decomposition approximation explains the RABBIT
phases in all three SBs qualitatively [12]. As expected,
its accuracy improves with increasing energy of the emitted
photoelectron. On the other hand, assuming ∆φcc to be
independent of the orbital angular momenta of the continuum
states leads to deviations from the analytical prediction,
particularly in the lower and the higher SB of the triplet at
low kinetic energies.
Even though starting with a 3pelectron still limits the
information that can be extracted due to the combined effect
of at least two Wigner and the cc phases, we decided to
perform the present proof-of-principle study on argon due to
its experimental advantages, including a significantly lower
ionization potential than helium, which may be a viable
alternative to atomic hydrogen due to its quasi-one-electron
character, as long as one of the electrons remains in the 1s
orbital, i.e., away from doubly-excited resonance states. In
argon, the intermediate orbital angular momentum after the
XUV step is λ=0 or 2, while λ=1 in helium. For the latter
target, as for atomic hydrogen, the dependence on the Wigner
phase would drop out, and the 3-SB setup would provide
direct access to the phase associated with higher-order cc
transitions [11, 12]. Nevertheless, a significant strength of our
current setup already lies in the fact that the results within each
group are independent of any chirp in the XUV pulse, because
the XUV harmonic pair is common to all three SBs.
This paper is organized as follows. We begin with a brief
review of the basic idea behind the 3-SB setup in Sec. II. This
is followed by a description of the experimental apparatus in
Sec. III and the accompanying theoretical R-matrix (close-
coupling) with time dependence (RMT) approach in Sec. IV.
In section V, we first show angle-integrated data (Sec. V A)
arXiv:2210.09244v2 [physics.atom-ph] 20 Jan 2023