
3
FIG. 4. (a) ED spectrum from cluster C6 [36] in the multiferroic
phase for ϵ−1= 0.287,dg/aM= 1 at filling νh= 1.NVlabels
the different spin-valley sectors, NV= (N+−N−). The inset
shows the low-lying manifold of states. There are 84 states below
the dashed line matching a Hilbert space dimension dimH= 2 ×
PNV≥0Nc
NV/2= 84 for Nc= 6 unit cells where the factor of 2
accounts for the two different sublattices (b) Energy splitting of the
ground states of the different phases upon the application of a small
displacement field Vzthat explicitly breaks the C2ysymmetry.
ferromagnetic order due to spin-valley polarization, as evident
in figure 3(a). The spin-valley ferromagnetism is of the Ising
type and corresponds to spontaneous symmetry breaking of
time-reversal symmetry. In addition to ferromagnetism, we
find the ground state in the majority of the phase diagram to
show strong layer polarization, i.e, ferroelectricity, by sponta-
neously breaking the C2ysymmetry. To characterize this, we
compute the layer polarization PLdefined in Eq. (2) and find
that it is non-zero, as shown in figure 3(b). The simultaneous
occurence of spin-valley ferromagnetism and ferroelectricity
corresponds to the multiferroic phase which is observed for
dg/aM≥0.2and ϵ−1≥0.11 [39].
Further evidence that the layer-swapping C2ysymmetry is
broken in the multiferroic phase may be gleaned from the re-
sponse of the ground states to a symmetry breaking pertur-
bation in the form of a tiny out of plane displacement field
Vz. When Vz= 0, the many-body multiferroic ground state
manifold is two-fold degenerate (see inset of Fig. 4(a)) if we
fix spin-valley polarization. The two degenerate states are re-
lated by C2y, and correspond to larger carrier density in the
top or bottom layer. The displacement field Vzis odd under
C2y, and therefore splits this degeneracy. Accordingly, as we
increase Vz, we find the two-fold degenerate ground states of
the multiferroic phase split linearly in Vzand flow in opposite
directions as shown in Fig. 4(b) — providing comprehensive
evidence of C2ybreaking. This behavior of the multiferroic
ground state manifold stands in sharp contrast to the ground
states of the competing Chern insulator phase, that is insen-
sitive to small displacement fields. Lastly, we note that the
parts of the phase diagram where we observe layer polariza-
tion also exhibit significantly large off-diagonal components
in the band basis [36]. This is consistent with our intuition
that the layer bases - an approximate eigenbasis for the multi-
ferroic - strongly mix the top and bottom bands. Indeed, such
band-mixing is expected for large values of ϵ−1where multi-
ferroicity is observed — interactions overcome the small band
gap between the two active bands.
Upon decreasing the screening length dg, the range of
Coulomb interaction is shortened in real space and we observe
a transition to a Chern insulator phase obtained by hole filling
one of the upper Chern band within one valley at νh= 1.
While the Chern insulator is still ferromagnetic in both orbital
(valley) and spin sectors, as indicated in Fig. 3(a), the fer-
roelectricity disappears as the Chern bands themselves have
almost equal spectral weight in both layers.
In addition to the fully symmetric metal, spin-valley po-
larized Chern insulator and multiferroic phases, we also find
signatures of an intermediate ferroelectric phase — character-
ized by non-zero layer polarization and vanishing valley po-
larization, between the metallic and the multiferroic phases.
In contrast to the rest of the phases, we find the existence of
this intermediate ferroelectric phase at νh= 1 to be sensitive
to the choice of the momentum space cluster used for ED [36].
Henceforth, we focus on understanding the rest of the phase
diagram, which is robust to the choice of momentum cluster.
The observed structure of the phase diagram in Fig 3(a-b)
for νh= 1, in particular the competition between the Chern
insulator and the multiferroic, can be understood from an ap-
proximate real space description of the flat bands. The layer-
projected wavefunctions of the two active bands in each spin-
valley sector are found [33,34] to be localized on atomic sites
that form a triangular lattice in each layer (Fig. 1(b)). In the
top layer, these atomic sites are denoted by RM
X, as metal (M)
atoms of the top layer are locally aligned with chalcogen (X)
atoms of the bottom layer within the moir´
e unit cell. In the
bottom layer, these sites are denoted by RX
M, as the chalco-
gen (X) atoms of the top layer are locally aligned with the
metal (M) atoms of the bottom layer. Taken together, the two
inter-penetrating triangular lattices from the two layers form a
honeycomb lattice at the moir´
e lengthscale.
This lattice structure combined with the opposite Chern
C=±1bands allows the construction of a tight-binding
model that provides a realization of Kane-Mele physics [40] at
the non-interacting level. Since states in the two layers are lo-
calized on the two sublattices RM
Xand RX
M, layer polarization
implies sublattice polarization. The reason for sublattice po-
larization for long-range repulsion is quite intuitive. For large
screening lengths dg, the interaction is essentially long range
— there is significant nearest-neighbor repulsion between the
electrons in addition to on-site repulsion. In this regime, the
electrons can minimize both on-site and nearest neighbor re-
pulsive interactions by localizing on a single triangular sub-
lattice of the effective honeycomb lattice (Fig. 1(c)), leading
to ferroelectric order.
The aforementioned real space picture is strongly reflected
in the many-body spectrum of the multiferroic phase (Fig.
4(a)) where we observe a low energy manifold of states sepa-
rated by a large gap from the rest of the spectrum. The number
of the low-lying states in this manifold is always consistent
with the expected dimension of a Hilbert space that is the sum