
Microwave–optical double resonance in a erbium-doped whispering-gallery-mode
resonator
Li Ma, Luke S. Trainor, Gavin G. G. King, Harald G. L. Schwefel, and Jevon J. Longdell∗
Dodd-Walls Centre for Photonic and Quantum Technologies, New Zealand and
Department of Physics, University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand
(Dated: Wednesday 26th October, 2022; 00:29)
We showcase an erbium-doped whispering-gallery-mode resonator with optical modes that display
intrinsic quality factors better than 108(linewidths less than 2 MHz), and coupling strengths to
collective erbium transitions of up to 2π×1.2 GHz – enough to reach the ensemble strong coupling
regime. Our optical cavity sits inside a microwave resonator, allowing us to probe the spin transition
which is tuned by an external magnetic field. We show a modified optically detected magnetic
resonance measurement that measures population transfer by a change in coupling strength rather
than absorption coefficient. This modification was enabled by the strong coupling to our modes, and
allows us to optically probe the spin transition detuned by more than the inhomogeneous linewidth.
We contrast this measurement with electron paramagnetic resonance to experimentally show that
our optical modes are confined in a region of large microwave magnetic field and we explore how
such a geometry could be used for coherent microwave–optical transduction.
I. INTRODUCTION
Rare earth ions in solids at low temperatures provide
a unique set of capabilities for coherently manipulating
information. The 4f−4ftransitions have very nar-
row homogeneous [1–3] and inhomogeneous [4,5] optical
linewidths, as well as long lived coherence times for both
nuclear [6] and electron spin transitions [7,8]. Large
optical absorption is possible, despite the weak optical
oscillator strengths, even to the point where negative re-
fractive index could be possible [9]. Furthermore, the use
of erbium dopants gives access to an optical transition at
1.5µm, in the center of the low-loss wavelength region
for optical fibers.
The properties of rare earth ion dopants have enabled
a number of advances in quantum memories [6,10], and
classical signal processing [11,12]. A particular ad-
vantage of using dopants over free space atoms is in-
creased flexibility when coupling the dopants to optical
resonators. The coupling of rare earth ion dopants to
nano-photonic resonators has enabled single site detec-
tion [13] as well as control and readout of single dopants
[14]. Meanwhile, the coupling of ensembles to macro-
scopic resonators has been investigated to improve quan-
tum memories [15], and microwave–optical transduction
[16–18].
Whispering gallery mode (WGM) resonators combine
extremely high quality (Q) factors and moderately small
mode volumes in a convenient monolithic form factor [19].
The guiding of light is provided by total internal reflec-
tion from the curved surface of the resonator’s rim. Thus
the resonators can operate over a wide range of wave-
lengths and can be made of any optical material that is
low loss and for which smooth surfaces can be prepared.
For example, recently Q-factors of 109have been demon-
strated [20] for yttrium orthosilicate (YSO) – a popular
∗jevon.longdell@otago.ac.nz
host for cryogenic rare earth ion dopants because of its
low density of spins.
The flexibility in material choice for WGM resonators
has allowed numerous nonlinear optical processes like
second-harmonic generation [21–23], Kerr solitons [24,
25] and optical parametric oscillation [26] in wide fre-
quency ranges. The high Q-factors have enabled ef-
ficient demonstrations of photon pair sources [27] and
allowed squeezing measurements of optical parametric
oscillation operated far above threshold [28]. Interfac-
ing a microwave field with the resonators has allowed
for electro-optic demonstrations such as efficient single-
sideband modulation [29] and electro-optic frequency
combs [30,31]. Coupling to ensemble spin states has
previously been achieved through the interaction with
magnon modes of yttrium iron garnet spheres [32].
Cryogenic rare earths in WGM resonators are rela-
tively unexplored, in spite of the promises of very Q-
factors for both the resonators and the ions. It has been
shown that being near to the surface in a WGM resonator
doesn’t adversely effect the ions spectral properties [33].
Optical photons have much higher energies and cou-
ple to matter more strongly than radio-frequency or mi-
crowave photons. This makes optically detected mag-
netic resonance (ODMR) a powerful technique for prob-
ing solid state spins. ODMR works by looking at spin-
state dependent changes in the amount of optical absorp-
tion or fluorescence level, as either property depends on
the population balance [34,35]. ODMR is a more sen-
sitive technique than EPR, not only due to the higher
energy probe photons, but also because thermal noise is
much lower at optical frequencies. The optical detection
significantly improves the sensitivity of magnetic reso-
nance spectroscopy and increases the fidelity and spatial
resolution of spin initialization and readout [36–38].
In our resonator we perform ODMR by monitoring
changes in the materials dispersion rather than absorp-
tion. This dispersive measurement is allowed by strong
coupling between an optical resonator mode and an en-
arXiv:2210.13793v1 [quant-ph] 25 Oct 2022