system thermalizes after some time. This thermalization takes place in the following sense:
although the time evolution is unitary, over time, the initial state becomes entangled with
the other states in the Hilbert space of the system. The information initially contained
only in the original state is distributed over the other states and is therefore mixed up.
Thus, the system “scrambles” [1,2] information. The characteristic time scale associated
with this process is called the scrambling time ts[1,2].
Before characterizing the scrambling time, we need to first address scrambling itself.
Following [1–3], which introduced the concept of scrambling, we call a system scrambled if
the information within it (i.e. the state of the system) is sufficiently distributed over the
entire Hilbert space of the system with respect to some chosen measure.
Note that we keep the definition general on purpose: we do not limit the formulation to
a specific measure of the uniformity of the state distribution. There exist multiple distinct
such measures defined in the literature. Some of the first explicit definitions include the
Haar measure in application to the choice of the mixing unitary transformation [1], or to
states (“Haar-scrambled”) [2]. Following [4], for a model of Kqubits in [2], the authors also
define a system to be “Page-scrambled” when the entanglement entropy of any subsystem
of n < K/2qubits satisfies Sn=n−O(exp[2n−K]). In general, a detailed picture
of scrambling, especially for black holes, requires an understanding of scrambling at a
microscopic level. In particular, the microscopic picture of scrambling, introduced in [5–9]
(see also further references therein), establishes the concept of “memory modes” (see the
discussion below). Moreover, it discusses the concepts and the corresponding time-scales
of “one-particle entanglement” [8] and “maximal entanglement” [9] for microscopic models
of black holes.
However, in the present work we introduce a novel regime, which takes place on time-
scales smaller than the various aforementioned scrambling time-scales. We thus establish
a new pre-scrambling stage of a system’s evolution, which requires quantification. In
addition, we note that the results of the present paper are independent of the choice of a
specific measure for scrambling.
What is the shortest possible scrambling time that a system can have? Following [1–
3], systems that scramble information in a time logarithmic in the number of degrees
of freedom are the quickest scramblers. As in [1–3], we refer to such systems as fast
scramblers. We broaden the above definition to also include the number of sites, modes,
or generic quantum labels in a system, in addition to the number of degrees of freedom.
Furthermore, to keep the definition general, we do not include any temperature dependence
or any bound due to the latter, as is, for example, done in [2,10–12] among many other
works. The results of the present paper apply in general, and require only that fast
scramblers have a scrambling time that is logarithmic in the number of degrees of freedom
K. The temperature dependent scrambling time for the model considered in section 2will
be analyzed elsewhere [13]. In this paper we investigate the behavior of the above model
at times preceding its scrambling time.
2