
3
−12 −8−4 0 4 8 12
−2
0
2
p[k]
q[k]
hvi
hvξihvνi
5vrec
−12−8−40 4 8 12
−5
0
5
p[k]
hvαiq[vrec]
hvξiqhvνiq
ab
FIG. 3. Frustration of motion in the bulk and anisotropic ballistic edge modes. (A) Evolution of the mean velocity
⟨v⟩versus momentum. The arrow is scaled according the mean velocity modulus. (B) Measurements of the q-average velocity
components versus p. The solid lines are the expected variations for the ground band of the Hamiltonian (1).
We first investigate the anomalous Hall drift in spin
space upon the application of a weak force in the xz
plane. For a force oriented along ˆ
µ(spatial direction con-
jugated to m), the spin projection probabilities Πmreveal
a drift of the mean spin projection ⟨m⟩, while the mean
remainder ⟨n⟩remain approximately constant (Fig. 2a).
An opposite behavior is observed when applying a force
along ˆ
ν(direction conjugated to n), with a quasi-linear
variation of ⟨n⟩while ⟨m⟩remains constant (Fig. 2b).
More generally, in the bulk of the system, where the band
dispersion can be neglected, the variation with momen-
tum of the mean values ⟨n⟩and ⟨m⟩can be expressed as
an anomalous Hall drift governed by the antisymmetric
Berry curvature tensor Ωbulk, as [31, 32]
d⟨rα⟩= Ωαβ
bulkdpβ,(4)
Ωbulk =B−1=1
2k
0 0 1 1
0 0 1 −2
−1−1 0 0
−1200
,(5)
where ris the position vector and dpis the momen-
tum variation due to the external force. We con-
front this prediction to our measurements of the mean
positions ⟨m⟩and ⟨n⟩as a function of p(Fig. 2c).
In the center of the Brillouin zone |p| ≤ 4k(bulk
mode region), we fit the measured Hall drift with the
linear function (4), yielding {Ωnx,Ωnz,Ωmx,Ωmz}=
{−1.00(2),−0.98(2),−0.98(2),1.96(2)}/(2k), consistent
with (5). We do not measure any significant spatial drift
upon the application of a force in the xz plane, consistent
with Ωxz = 0. Similarly, no Hall current along nis mea-
sured when applying a force along m(corresponding to
a perturbative Zeeman field), compatible with Ωnm = 0
[30].
Further insight on the ground band properties is pro-
vided by the mean velocity ⟨v⟩(Fig. 3), which reveals
distinct behaviours between bulk and the edge modes.
In the bulk |p|≲7k, the mean velocity remains much
smaller than the recoil velocity vrec =k/M (Fig. 3b).
Since ⟨v⟩=∇pE0, it confirms that the ground band
energy E0is quasi-flat in the bulk (Fig. 1d). This mea-
surement illustrates the frustration of motion induced by
the magnetic field, similarly to flat Landau levels in 2D
electron gases.
For p≳7k, the atoms mostly occupy the edge redge =
Jˆ
mof the synthetic dimension m. We measure a non-
zero mean velocity, whose ξcomponent increases with
p, while the νprojection remains small (Fig. 3b). This
observation is characteristic of an anisotropic edge mode
of a 4D quantum Hall system, which corresponds to a
collection of 1D conduction channels oriented along the
direction wmotion, with wα
motion ∝Ωαβ
bulkredge
β,here corre-
sponding to the direction ˆ
ξ[21]. Within the edge, the
motion in the plane orthogonal to wmotion remains in-
hibited, in agreement with the measured νvelocity. A
similar behaviour is found on the edge −Jˆ
m, albeit with
opposite orientation of velocity.
A hallmark of 4D quantum Hall physics is the peculiar
nature of excitations above the ground band, which can
be linked to classical cyclotron trajectories. While cy-
clotron motion in 2D and 3D always corresponds to pla-
nar circular orbits, we expect more complex trajectories
in 4D, involving two planar rotations occurring at differ-
ent rates. In our system, each of these two elementary
excitations is generated by the Raman coupling along x
or z, of corresponding frequencies ωxand ωzindepen-
dently set by the amplitudes txand tz. We excite the
atoms by applying a diabatic velocity kick, and measure
the subsequent time evolution of the center of mass. We
show in Fig. 4a the orbit measured for ωz/ωx≃2, reveal-
ing a non-planar trajectory. For this integer frequency
ratio, the orbit is almost closed, and is reminiscent of a
Lissajous orbit (Fig. 4b). We also studied the case of de-
generate frequencies ωz≃ωx, which correspond to the
coupling amplitudes used for our study of the ground
band. In this ‘isoclinic’ case, we recover a planar cy-
clotron motion akin to lower-dimensional cyclotron orbits
(Fig. 4c,d).
The non-trivial topology of a quantum Hall system
manifests in the quantization of its electromagnetic re-
sponse. While involving the linear Hall conductance in
2D, it requires in 4D considering the non-linear response
to both an electric force fand a magnetic field b. These
two perturbations induce a current
jα
non-linear =C2
4π2ϵαβγδfδbβγ ,
where ϵαβγδ is the 4D Levi-Civita symbol and C2is the
integer second Chern number [14]. In other words, the
magnetic field bβγ induces a Hall effect in the perpendic-
ular plane.
We first demonstrate the quantization of the non-linear