
straightforward work of repairs and downloads, all that Kirk and his personnel could offer was a certain
amount of detective work. Some data could be recovered from the repaired data base and retrieval
systems, but people trained in archaeology, historiography, and anthropology would have to ferret out the
rest. The restoration[7]would require a number of searches, and they had to face the possibility that some
data might be permanently lost.
Spock had a theory, which he had been testing as often as practical, that the virus had not destroyed all
of the data, but had merely “hidden” at least some of it. If he was even partially right, Kirk knew that a lot
of hard work in search of physical records could be avoided.
The people on the four worlds that theEnterprise had already visited had been understandably irritated,
even angry about the damage to their data bases. Kirk recalled how distressed the Lurissan Guides, the
governing body of Cynur IV, had been when he had first met with them. The people of Cynur IV had a
reputation as some of the warmest and most hospitable beings in the Federation; but the Cynurians Kirk
had encountered had taken every opportunity to gripe and rail against the Federation for its carelessness;
their hospitality had been grudging at best. He had no reason to expect the Tyrtaeans to be any more
amenable, especially when they learned that perhaps not everything in their data base could be restored.
They also, Kirk reminded himself, had other reasons for not welcoming Starfleet personnel. Unlike the
other four affected worlds, the Tyrtaeans had joined the Federation grudgingly. Their ancestors had left
Earth a century ago; the Federation was a reminder of the world they had sought to escape.
[8]Spock was still studying the strange object on the sensor screen.
“It’s ironic,” Kirk said. “The people of Tyrtaeus II pride themselves on withstanding adversity with
forbearance. They scorn luxury, and think public displays of strong emotion are offensive. They have the
reputation of being one of the more stoic and severe people in the galaxy. Now they are faced with a
threat to their most ethereal artifact—their recorded culture. And that part of their civilization—the least
practical and most unnecessary part—that is what they have complained about most keenly.”
“I do not find that ironic, Captain,” Spock said without turning from the screen. “What is most necessary
for any being, all other things being given, is to maintain its identity, which is also essential to any culture.
Irony, as I understand it, seems a superficial interpretation of the situation in this case. Least practical and
most unnecessary is not how their loss should be described. What would you have the Tyrtaeans
conclude? That they can do without what is apparently lost?”
Kirk considered for a moment. “You’re right, of course. They might complain a bit less, though.” He
leaned closer to Spock to view the screen, where the heat signature of the mysterious object was still
increasing. “We’ll have to find out what that is,” he added, “as soon as we’ve finished our job on
Tyrtaeus II.”
Spock nodded, as if approving of his curiosity,[9]then said, “I trust that it will be enough for the
Tyrtaeans to learn that less was lost than they feared. It is fortunate that they overcame their reluctance
and downloaded much of their data base in recent cultural exchanges. We will be able to restore all of
what they downloaded at that time.”
“Some of them won’t be satisfied, Spock. Much of their cultural identity, as you say, was in those
records.”
“Kind of an insular culture,” Uhura murmured, “from what the records indicate.”