archer's line met the river. "General Batu, take your army and reinforce your
archers," the minister said. "Anchor your line here, at the river, and deploy as
if expecting a frontal attack. Leave your western flank exposed."
A knot of anger formed in Batu's heart. He openly frowned at the minister,
hardly able to believe what he had heard. "If I do that, the barbarian cavalry
will ride down the line and drive my army into the river."
"Exactly," Kwan said, pulling his gray lips into a thin smile.
Shengti studied the scrying basin for a moment, then said, "A brilliant plan,
Minister! The sloppy deployment will lure the enemy into full commitment. As
the barbarians roll up Batu's flank, my army—along with the Army of Ching
Tung, of course—will charge over the hill and smash them."
The ancient minister smiled warmly at Shengti. "You are very astute," he
said. "Your future will have many bright days."
And my future will be very short, Batu thought. Shengti had neglected to
mention the most clever part of Kwan's plan: a troublesome subordinate
would be destroyed. Even if Batu did not perish during the slaughter, the
stigma of losing an entire army would destroy his career.
Still, even knowing the consequences, Batu's instinct was to follow the
order without question. To his way of thinking, soldiers were dead men. Their
commanders simply allowed them to walk the land of the living until their
bodies were needed in combat. In that respect, Batu considered himself no
different from any other soldier, and if Kwan ordered him to meet the enemy
naked and alone, he would be obliged to do so.
Still, a soldier was entitled to the hope of a glorious end. The young general
could see no glory in allowing the horse-warriors to slaughter his army like so
many swine, especially when Kwan had not taken the time to scout the enemy
and could not be certain that anything useful would come of the sacrifice.
Hoping to convince the generals from Shengti and Ching Tung to come to his
aid, Batu decided to point out Kwan's sloppy preparations.
"While your plan has many things to recommend it, Minister," he began, "I
must point out that it may result in the destruction of my army without
accomplishing the emperor's will."
Kwan settled back into his chair, placing his elbows on the armrests and
lacing his fingers in front of his body. "Please proceed, General," he said,
looking Batu in the eye with a milky but steady gaze. "I'm sure we're all
interested in your opinion."
The general from Chukei looked at his two peers. They stood well away,
their expressionless attention politely fixed on his face. After taking a deep
breath, Batu turned back to Kwan. The minister had shifted his gaze to a
space just over his subordinate's head.
"You're underestimating the barbarian's strength and sophistication," Batu
said. "By exposing my army's flank, you're assuring its pointless destruction."
The minister's expression did not change. He simply sat quietly, waiting for
his subordinate to continue, as if what he had said so far was of no
consequence.
Batu pointed toward the battlefield. "You're assuming the barbarians have
no plans of their own, and that they'll walk blindly into any trap you lay." The
young general waved his hand at his two peers. "If the enemy outnumbers us,
its flank guard will engage the armies of Shengti and Ching Tung on the
hilltop. They'll never reach the battlefield."