Geometry-induced spin-filtering in photoemission maps from WTe2surface states
Tristan Heider,1Gustav Bihlmayer,2Jakub Schusser,3, 4 Friedrich Reinert,4
Jan Min´ar,3Stefan Bl¨ugel,2Claus M. Schneider,1, 5, 6 and Lukasz Plucinski1, ∗
1Peter Gr¨unberg Institut (PGI-6), Forschungszentrum J¨ulich GmbH, 52428 J¨ulich, Germany
2Peter Gr¨unberg Institut (PGI-1) and Institute for Advanced Simulation (IAS-1),
Forschungszentrum J¨ulich and JARA, 52428 J¨ulich, Germany
3New Technologies-Research Center, University of West Bohemia, 30614 Pilsen, Czech Republic
4Experimentelle Physik VII and W¨urzburg-Dresden Cluster of Excellence ct.qmat, Universit¨at W¨urzburg, W¨urzburg, Germany
5Fakult¨at f¨ur Physik, Universit¨at Duisburg-Essen, 47048 Duisburg, Germany
6Physics Department, University of California, Davis, CA 95616, USA
(Dated: October 21, 2022)
We demonstrate that an important quantum material WTe2exhibits a new type of geometry-
induced spin-filtering effect in photoemission, stemming from low symmetry that is responsible for
its exotic transport properties. Through the laser-driven spin-polarized angle-resolved photoemis-
sion Fermi surface mapping, we showcase highly asymmetric spin textures of electrons photoemitted
from the surface states of WTe2. Such asymmetries are not present in the initial state spin textures,
which are bound by the time-reversal and crystal lattice mirror plane symmetries. The findings are
reproduced qualitatively by theoretical modeling within the one-step model photoemission formal-
ism. The effect could be understood within the free-electron final state model as an interference due
to emission from different atomic sites. The observed effect is a manifestation of time-reversal sym-
metry breaking of the initial state in the photoemission process, and as such it cannot be eliminated,
but only its magnitude influenced, by special experimental geometries.
Introduction.—WTe2is a semi-metallic two-
dimensional (2D) quantum material that exhibits a
non-saturating magnetoresistance up to 60 T [1]. It
has been debated, whether the bulk electron and hole
pockets in WTe2slightly overlap leading to the Weyl
type-II topological phase [2, 3], with a conjecture that
the surface electronic structure would be virtually
indistinguishable for a topological and trivial phases [4].
When thinned down to a monolayer, WTe2enables the
realization of high-temperature quantum Hall phases
[5] and gate-controlled superconductivity [6, 7]. In
non-magnetic systems the first-order Hall response
vanishes at zero magnetic field due to symmetry ar-
guments. However, the second-order correction leads
to the recently discovered [8–11] non-linear Hall effect
(NLHE) in systems of reduced symmetry. Few-layer
WTe2has been the first system in which the NLHE has
been demonstrated [9, 10] due to the presence of a single
mirror plane, and a related existence of polar axes both
in-plane and out-of-plane of the layers.
Early high resolution angle-resolved photoemission
(ARPES) on WTe2[12, 13] have focused on imaging
bulk electron and hole pockets with the motivation to ex-
plain the non-saturating magnetoresistance, pointing to a
possible full charge compensation at lower temperatures.
The prediction of possible type-II Weyl states in WTe2
[2] have further motivated the research on its electronic
structure. The reduced symmetry of WTe2results in in-
equivalent top and bottom surfaces along the c-axis. The
general shape of the experimental WTe2band dispersions
over the scale of 2 eV below the Fermi level is well repro-
duced by ab initio calculations, however, as pointed out
in an early study [12], density functional theory (DFT)
calculations are not able to quantitatively reproduce crit-
ical features of the WTe2electronic structure near the
Fermi level. In particular, this concerns the positions of
the electron and hole pockets and related sizes of their
Fermi surfaces [14] which play a critical role in under-
standing the magnetoresistance properties [12, 15]. This
lack of agreement, despite occurring on a small energy
scale of only 50 meV, is surprising because WTe2(001)
surfaces are clearly very stable under UHV yielding quan-
titatively consistent results in high-resolution ARPES for
the set of dispersive occupied features located near the
Fermi level [4, 12–14, 16–18].
Using the newly-developed high resolution laser-
driven spin-polarized ARPES (SARPES) spectrometer
we demonstrate for the first time the spin texture of the
Fermi level photoemission map measured with 6 eV pho-
tons. Previous SARPES studies only probed selected
regions in the Brillouin zone (BZ) [19–21]. We further
demonstrate that the symmetry of the ARPES spin tex-
ture reflects the WTe2surface symmetry with a sin-
gle mirror plane present, and not the initial state spin
symmetry. Therefore, we directly demonstrate that the
ARPES photocurrent carries additional information be-
yond the initial band structure spin texture, due to what
we call the geometry-induced spin filtering effect.
The results are analyzed by comparison to the dedi-
cated theoretical DFT calculations. The results obtained
within the linearized-augmented plane-wave (LAPW)
scheme show that the initial state spin texture follows
the expected axial vector transformation rules of a single
mirror plane and time-reversal. Further one-step model
photoemission calculations within the Korringa-Kohn-
Rostoker (KKR) scheme reproduce the (broken) symme-
arXiv:2210.10870v1 [cond-mat.mtrl-sci] 19 Oct 2022