
Quantum steering in a star network
Guangming Jiang,1Xiaohua Wu,1, ∗and Tao Zhou2, 3, †
1College of Physical Science and Technology, Sichuan University, Chengdu 610064, China
2Quantum Optoelectronics Laboratory, School of Physical Science and Technology,
Southwest Jiaotong University, Chengdu 610031, China
3Department of Applied Physics, School of Physical Science and Technology,
Southwest Jiaotong University, Chengdu 611756, China
(Dated: April 18, 2024)
In this work, we will consider the star network scenario where the central party is trusted while all the edge
parties (with a number of n) are untrusted. Network steering is defined with an nlocal hidden state model which
can be viewed as a special kind of nlocal hidden variable model. Two different types of sufficient criteria,
nonlinear steering inequality and linear steering inequality will be constructed to verify the quantum steering
in a star network. Based on the linear steering inequality, how to detect the network steering with a fixed
measurement will be discussed.
PACS numbers: 03.65.Ud, 03.65.Ta
I. INTRODUCTION
In 1930s, the concept of steering was introduced by
Schr¨
odinger [1] as a generalization of the Einstein-Podolsky-
Rosen (EPR) paradox [2]. For a bipartite state, steering in-
fers that an observer on one side can affect the state of the
other spatially separated system by local measurements. In
2007, a standard formalism of quantum steering was devel-
oped by Wiseman, Jones and Doherty [3]. In quantum infor-
mation processing, EPR steering can be defined as the task
for a referee to determine whether one party shares entangle-
ment with a second untrusted party [3–5]. Quantum steering
is a type of quantum nonlocality that is logically distinct from
inseparability [6,7] and Bell nonlocality [8].
In the last decade, the investigation of nonlocality has
moved beyond Bell’s theorem to consider more sophisticated
experiments that involve several independent sources which
distribute shares of physical systems among many parties in
a network [9–11]. The discussions, which are about the main
concepts, methods, results and future challenges in the emerg-
ing topic of Bell in networks, can be found in the review ar-
ticle [12]. The independence of various sources leads to non-
convexity in the space of relevant correlations [13–21].
The simplest network scenario is provided by entanglement
swapping [22]. To contrast classical and quantum correlation
in this scenario, the so-called bilocality assumption where the
classical models consist of two independent local hidden vari-
ables (LHV), has been considered [9,10]. The generaliza-
tion of the bilocality scenario to network, is the so-called n-
locality scenario, where the number of independent sources of
states is increased to arbitrary n[14–16,23–25]. Some new
interesting effects, such as the possibility to certify quantum
nonlocality “without inputs”, are offered by the network struc-
ture [10,11,26,27].
The quantum network scenarios, where some of the par-
ties are trusted while the others are untrusted, are natu-
∗wxhscu@scu.edu.cn
†taozhou@swjtu.edu.cn
rally connected to the notion of quantum steering. Though
the notion of multipartite steering has been previously con-
sidered [28,29], the steering in the scenario of network
with independent sources is seldom discussed. In the re-
cent work [30], focusing on the linear network with trusted
end points and intermediated untrusted parties who perform a
fixed measurement, the authors introduced the network steer-
ing and network local hidden state models. Motivated by the
work in Ref. [30], the steering in a star network will be con-
sidered here.
An important example for a multiparty network is a star-
shaped configuration. Such a star network is composed of a
central party that is separately connected, via a number of nin-
dependent bipartite sources, to nedge parties. Correlations in
the network arise through the central party jointly measuring
the nindependent shares received from the sources and edge
parties locally measuring the single shares received from the
corresponding sources. In the present work, we consider the
star network scenario where the central party is trusted while
all the edge parties are untrusted.
In this work, the quantum steering in a star network is de-
fined by introducing of an n-local hidden state (LHS) model.
It will be shown that this n-LHS model can be viewed as a
special kind of n-LHV model developed in [14–16,23–25].
Besides the n-LHS model, we will focus on how to verify
the quantum steering in the star network. Two different types
of sufficient criteria, linear steering inequality and nonlinear
steering inequality, will be designed. Unlike detecting steer-
ing with single source, it will be shown that the network steer-
ing can be demonstrated with a fixed measurement performed
by the trusted central party.
The content of this work is organized as follows. In Sec. II,
we give a brief review on the definition of steering in bipar-
tite system. In Sec. III, for a star network scenario where the
central party is trusted while all the edge parties are untrusted,
network steering is defined with an n-LHS model. To verify
the network steering, the nonlinear steering inequality, linear
steering inequality, are designed in Sec. IV, and Sec. V, re-
spectively. Finally, we end our work with a short conclusion.
arXiv:2210.01430v2 [quant-ph] 17 Apr 2024