
Quantum Thermodynamics applied for Quantum Refrigerators cooling down a qubit
Hideaki Okane,1Shunsuke Kamimura,1, 2 Shingo Kukita,3Yasushi Kondo,3and Yuichiro Matsuzaki1, 4, ∗
1Research Center for Emerging Computing Technologies (RCECT),
National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology (AIST),
1-1-1, Umezono, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-8568, Japan
2Faculty of Pure and Applied Sciences, University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba 305-8571, Japan
3Department of Physics, Kindai University, Higashi-Osaka 577-8502, Japan and
4NEC-AIST Quantum Technology Cooperative Research Laboratory,
National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology (AIST), Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-8568, Japan
(Dated: October 7, 2022)
We discuss a quantum refrigerator to increase the ground state probability of a target qubit
whose energy difference between the ground and excited states is less than the thermal energy of
the environment. We consider two types of quantum refrigerators: (1) one extra qubit with frequent
pulse operations and (2) two extra qubits without them. These two types of refrigerators are
evaluated from the viewpoint of quantum thermodynamics. More specifically, we calculate the heat
removed from the target qubit, the work done for the system, and the coefficient of performance
(COP), the ratio between the heat ant the work. We show that the COP of the second type
outperforms that of the first type. Our results are useful to design a high-performance quantum
refrigerator cooling down a qubit.
I. INTRODUCTION
Thermodynamics has traditionally explained macro-
scopic behavior of classical systems. For example, a re-
frigerator is essential not only for daily life but also for
academic purposes. We need a refrigerator for realizing
interesting phenomena, such as superfluidity, supercon-
ductivity, Bose-Einstein Condensation, and so on [1].
On the other hand, many efforts have been devoted to
extending the conventional thermodynamics to the quan-
tum one [2–5]. Such an extension is called quantum ther-
modynamics. Quantum thermodynamics define the ther-
modynamic properties of microscopic systems: heat and
work. Quantum thermodynamics helps to understand a
quantum refrigerator, which increases the population of
the ground state of a target quantum system. To quan-
tify the performance of a quantum refrigerator, quanti-
ties such as coefficient of performance (COP) and cooling
power are evaluated [6–10].
Electron spin resonance (ESR) is an important tech-
nique to detect target electron spins, which gives informa-
tion of various materials [11]. ESR has recently been per-
formed with several types of quantum detectors such as
a superconducting circuit [12–24] and nitrogen vacancy
(NV) centers [25–31]. Such a kind of detector can also
be utilized as a quantum refrigerator to polarize target
spins [32, 33]. To improve the sensitivity of the ESR,
polarizing the target spins is essential. Therefore, eval-
uation of a quantum refrigerator should contribute to a
further improvement of the ESR sensitivity.
In this work, we evaluate the performance of two
types of quantum refrigerators: (1) one extra qubit
with frequent pulse operations and (2) two extra qubits
∗matsuzaki.yuichiro@aist.go.jp
without them. The former corresponds to the realized
scheme [32, 33]. The latter is a newly proposed method
in this paper, in which one of the extra qubits is for quan-
tum control and the other is for the heat release to the
environment. We calculate the heat removed from the
target qubit, the work done for the system, and the COP
for these two approaches. According to the analysis of
them based on quantum thermodynamics, we find that
the latter outperforms the former in terms of the COP.
The rest of this paper is organized as follows. §II
reviews the definition of heat and work in the bipartite
quantum system, based on Ref. [34]. We present two
models with and without frequent reset in §III and an-
alyze their performance from the viewpoint of quantum
thermodynamics in §IV. §V summarizes our results. In
appendix A, we explain the possible experimental realiza-
tion of our scheme with current technology. In appendix
B, we explain the detail of the conventional protocol. In
appencix C, we calculate the work necessary for a qubit
initialization. We take the natural unit system and thus
we omit ~and kBin this paper.
II. THE DEFINITION OF WORK AND HEAT
BETWEEN INTERACTING BIPARTITE
SYSTEMS
Let us review the definition of work and heat trans-
ferred between an interacting bipartite quantum system
(a target and extra qubits) based on quantum thermo-
dynamics [34]. In order to quantify the cooling effect, we
need to evaluate a heat transfer from the target qubit to
the extra qubit.
To calculate heat and work in a quantum system, we
need to define an internal energy. In a single system
with a Hamiltonian Hand a density matrix ρ, the in-
ternal energy is defined as Tr(ρH). By differentiating
arXiv:2210.02681v1 [quant-ph] 6 Oct 2022