1
OPTIMAL HYBRID MULTIPLEXED
AC-DC-AC POWER CONVERTERS
Matthew Deakin 1*
1Department of Engineering, Newcastle University, Newcastle-upon-Tyne, UK
*email: matthew.deakin@newcastle.ac.uk
Keywords: HYBRID POWER ELECTRONICS, AC-DC-AC CONVERTER, MULTIPORT CONVERTER,
MULTI-TERMINAL SOFT OPEN POINT
Abstract
The flexibility of multi-terminal AC-DC-AC converters connected in distribution networks can be increased by changing the
sizes of the individual AC-DC converter stages and connecting the AC side of those converters to electromechanical switches
(multiplexers) to allow reconfiguration within the network. The combinations of real powers that can be transferred by such a
design can be described using a capability chart. In this work, it is proposed that the area of these capability charts is a meaningful
metric for describing the flexibility of such a device. These capability chart areas are calculated in closed form for a three-
terminal AC-DC-AC device consisting of three AC-DC converters of arbitrary sizes, allowing the optimal AC-DC converter
sizing to be determined to maximise this area. It is shown that this optimal design yields a capability chart area that is 64%
larger than the equivalent area from a conventional equally-sized AC-DC-AC converter. Converters which are optimal in other
senses are discussed, such as a design with 10% increased per-feeder real power transfer, albeit with an 8% area reduction. It is
concluded that the capability chart area is an intuitive and informative approach for describing the increased flexibility of
multiplexed AC-DC-AC converters.
1 Introduction
Electrical distribution systems require new, flexible capacity
to enable consumers to connect low carbon technologies such
as electric vehicles, heat pumps and solar photovoltaics (PV).
One way of increasing this network capacity is through AC-
DC-AC converters (called, amongst others, Soft Open Points,
DC Links, Solid State Transformers, Smart Transformers, etc)
[1]. These solutions can be installed in substations [2], in place
of normally open points [1], or in parallel with switchgear [3].
It is well-known that these solutions are typically more
expensive than conventional approaches of providing network
capacity [2]. As a result, there has been interest in proposing
Hybrid AC-DC-AC solutions that make use of low-cost
electromechanical switches to increase the flexibility of these
designs. For example, the Hybrid Open Point [1] installs AC-
DC-AC power converters in parallel with switchgear to
increase operational and planning flexibility. In the past, cost-
effective hybrid approaches have allowed increased market
share [4].
This work considers the novel Hybrid AC-DC-AC
configuration shown in Figure 1, first introduced in [5] as the
Hybrid Multi-Terminal Soft Open Point (Hybrid MTSOP).
This approach uses multiplexers (‘Feeder Selector Switches’)
to allow any converter to connect to any of the distribution
feeders at a node. It is shown that this enlarges the capability
chart of the device, increasing the power that can be transferred
by 50% and increasing the loss reduction capabilities by 13%.
The approach shows similarities with the ‘MVAC switchyard’
described in [6], which also uses multiplexers to reconfigure
power electronics to improve network capacity. It also shows
some parallels with the hybrid EV charger described in [7],
which also uses a multiplexer (‘relay matrix’) to increase the
flexibility of the outputs of a vehicle-to-grid charger, or the
phase changing soft open point [13]. On the power electronics
side, there is also a large literature on the design of multiport
converters that make efficient use of components (e.g.,
reduced numbers of solid-state switches through interleaving
[8] or developing systematic strategies for designing
topologies with low component count [9]). However, to the
best of the author’s knowledge, there is no explicit
quantification of the area of the increased capability charts that
such a Hybrid Multiplexed AC-DC-AC system can provide.
As capability charts are intuitive and well-known methods of
presenting information about device flexibility, this is a
significant gap.
In this paper, we address this gap by quantifying the area of
the capability chart of a three-terminal Hybrid AC-DC-AC
converter for any given set of three converter sizes. It is shown
that it is feasible to evaluate the capability chart analytically,
allowing the optimal converter design (in terms of maximum
capability chart area) to be determined. A number of further
cases of interest are also described to highlight the properties
of the capability chart areas and more generally properties of
Hybrid Multiplexed AC-DC-AC converters.
The structure of this paper is as follows. In Section 2, we define
the AC-DC-AC capability chart area, to show the sense in
which this metric describes operational flexibility achieved by
designs using the multiplexed approach. In Section 3, we
proceed to calculate these areas analytically for three
combinations of systems, enabling a utility to understand the
potential benefits of the approach quantitively. Finally, in
Section 4 we draw salient conclusions.