Origin of negative electrocaloric effect in Pnma -type antiferroelectric perovskites
Ningbo Fan,1, 2 Jorge ´
I˜niguez,3, 4 L. Bellaiche,5and Bin Xu1, 2, ∗
1Institute of Theoretical and Applied Physics, Soochow University, Suzhou 215006, China
2School of Physical Science and Technology, Soochow University, Suzhou 215006, China
3Materials Research and Technology Department,
Luxembourg Institute of Science and Technology (LIST),
Avenue des Hauts-Fourneaux 5, L-4362 Esch/Alzette, Luxembourg
4Department of Physics and Materials Science, University of Luxembourg, Rue du Brill 41, L-4422 Belvaux, Luxembourg
5Physics Department and Institute for Nanoscience and Engineering,
University of Arkansas, Fayetteville, Arkansas 72701, USA
(Dated: October 11, 2022)
Anomalous electrocaloric effect (ECE) with decreasing temperature upon application of an electric
field is known to occur in antiferroelectrics (AFEs), and previous understanding refers to the field-
induced canting of electric dipoles if there is no phase transitions. Here, we use a first-principle-
based method to study the ECE in Nd-substituted BiFeO3(BNFO) perovskite solid solutions, which
has the Pnma-type AFE ground state. We demonstrate another scenario to achieve and explain
anomalous ECE, emphasizing that explicit consideration of octahedral tiltings is indispensable for
a correct understanding. This mechanism may be general for AFEs for which the antipolar mode is
not the primary order parameter. We also find that the negative ECE can reach a large magnitude
in BNFO.
Electrocaloric effect (ECE) can make temperature
change via adiabatic application (or removal) of an elec-
tric field, providing an efficient approach for cooling or
heating [1–3]. While ferroelectric (FE) or relaxor mate-
rials typically have “normal” positive sign of ECE, i.e.,
the temperature increases by applying a voltage, antifer-
roelectrics (AFEs) are known to have anomalous ECE
that can yield an opposite sign [4–6] . These two types
of ECE can be utilized in combination to improve the
performance of cooling/heating devices.
Such negative (or inverse) caloric effect is also known
to occur in other occasions, e.g., magnetic Heusler alloys,
transitions between FE phases of different polarization
directions, and application of an electric field against the
polarization of a FE phase without switching [7–9]; how-
ever, its origin in AFEs is less well understood. AFEs
materials are characterized by anti-polar atomic distor-
tions that can be switched to a FE state under an electric
field, and two mechanisms to explain their negative ECE
with no AFE-FE transition have been proposed: 1) the
“dipole-canting” model that dipolar entropy increases by
misaligning the anti-parallel dipoles upon application of
the field [5]; 2) the perturbative theory based on the
Maxwell relation that only temperature and electric field
dependencies of polarization need to be considered [10].
Interestingly, all these mechanisms only take the electric
degrees of freedom explicitly into account. In contrast,
most of the known AFEs are neither proper type (that
is, the AFE phase is rarely driven by an AFE soft mode
[11]), nor systems with the anti-polar mode being the
only significant order parameter. In fact, quite often, the
AFE mode is secondary and coupled to other degrees of
freedom, such as the octahedral tiltings in perovskites.
For instance, PZO has a strong instability of anti-phase
octahedral tilting [12], while in Pnma-type perovskite,
such as rare earth orthoferrites and CsPbI3, the anti-
polar distortion arises from the condensation of both the
in-plane anti-phase (ωRx,y ) and out-of-plane in-phase tilt-
ings (ωMz) via trilinear coupling [13]. Although these
tilting modes are non-polar, they couple strongly with
the polar and anti-polar modes so that they can be in-
fluenced by the electric field as well, and in consequence
contribute to the ECE.
To get a deeper understanding of the (negative) ECE
in AFE, analysis based on Landau models involving the
most relevant degrees of freedom have been proved to be
very useful [14–17], and it may thus be necessary that all
the important order parameters are taken into consid-
eration. Furthermore, some previous phenomenological
models are often over simplified, since only one dimen-
sion is assumed [4]. In reality, the direction of the ap-
plied field with respect to the crystallographic axis should
have different effects regarding ECE. In this Letter, we
take the antiferroelectric Nd substituted BiFeO3(BNFO)
solid solution as an example and demonstrate that the
octahedral tiltings can have very important effect on the
sign and magnitude of the ECE. We also construct a
phenomenological model that allows us to rationalize the
contributions of each degree of freedom. In particular,
the dipoles alone are found to be insufficient to explain
the negative ECE, while contributions from the in-phase
and anti-phase tilting modes are indispensible. More-
over, BNFO is predicted to yield rather large negative
ECE close to the AFE-to-FE transition.
BiFeO3(BFO) stabilizes in a R3c ground state, but
rare-earth doping with composition larger than 20−30%
is sufficient to alter it to the Pnma structure [18]. Here,
we adopt the effective Hamiltonian scheme of Ref. [19]
to study the Bi0.6Nd0.4FeO3solid solution under elec-
tric field at finite temperatures. With this composition,
arXiv:2210.04138v1 [cond-mat.mtrl-sci] 9 Oct 2022