
Superconducting proximity effect and long-ranged triplets in dirty metallic antiferromagnets
Eirik Holm Fyhn,
1
Arne Brataas,
1
Alireza Qaiumzadeh,
1
and Jacob Linder
1
1
Center for Quantum Spintronics, Department of Physics, Norwegian
University of Science and Technology, NO-7491 Trondheim, Norway
(Dated: May 30, 2023)
Antiferromagnets have no net spin-splitting on the scale of the superconducting coherence length. Despite
this, antiferromagnets have been observed to suppress superconductivity in a similar way as ferromagnets, a
phenomenon that still lacks a clear understanding. We find that this effect can be explained by the role of impurities
in antiferromagnets. Using quasiclassical Green’s functions, we study the proximity effect and critical temperature
in diffusive superconductor-metallic antiferromagnet bilayers. The non-magnetic impurities acquire an effective
magnetic component in the antiferromagnet. This not only reduces the critical temperature but also separates the
superconducting correlations into short-ranged and long-ranged components, similar to ferromagnetic proximity
systems.
Introduction: Antiferromagnets and superconductors
both have prominent roles in condensed matter physics [
1
–
9
]. Separately, they are both theoretically interesting due to
their different types of quantum order [
10
–
13
]. They are also
technologically useful: superconductors in part because of
their perfect diamagnetism and dissipationless current [
14
,
15
],
and antiferromagnets because of their ultrafast dynamics [
16
,
17
], negligible stray-field and considerable magnetotransport
effects [
1
]. However, while materials with superconducting or
magnetic properties can be interesting on their own, new physics
and applications can be found in systems that combine both. For
instance, combining superconductivity and ferromagnetism in
mesoscopic heterostructures is now a well-established method
to produce odd-frequency superconductivity and long-range
spin-triplet superconductivity [
13
,
18
]. The latter can carry
dissipationless spin-currents, giving superconductors a unique
role in the field of spintronics [2].
Superconductor-antiferromagnet (SC-AF) heterostructures
have been studied both theoretically and experimentally [
19
–
30
], but much less than their ferromagnetic counterparts. As a
result, much remains to be fully understood about SC-AF het-
erostructures. For instance, experiments show that proximity
to antiferromagnets can severely suppress the superconduct-
ing critical temperature [
28
–
30
]. This suppression is much
stronger than the prediction by the theoretical models which
considered the AFs to be similar to normal metals due to their
lack of uncompensated magnetic moments [
29
–
31
]. In fact, the
suppression has been reported to be even larger than the suppres-
sion seen in ferromagnetic junctions [
28
]. Various proposals
have been suggested to explain this suppression, such as finite
spin-splitting coming from uncompensated interfaces [
30
], the
possibility of magnetic impurities having been infused into the
superconductor during sample preparation [
28
], or the complex
spin structure of the specific antiferromagnetic materials used
in the experiments [29].
More recently, in a theoretical study of superconductor-
antiferromagnetic insulator bilayers with compensated inter-
faces, Bobkov et al.
[32]
suggested that a band-gap opening
mechanism together with the induction of spin-triplet Cooper
pairs could explain the suppression. As these effects are smaller
when the mean free path is shorter, they argued that the sup-
pression would be larger for cleaner systems, but noted that a
fully detailed analysis of the roles of impurities and AF length
should consider a metallic AF.
Here, we study the proximity effect in diffusive supercon-
ductor (SC)-antiferromagnetic metal (AFM) bilayers using our
newly derived quasiclassical framework [
33
]. Interestingly, our
results show that the suppression of superconductivity is not
larger for clean systems, but that impurity scattering is in fact
the dominant mechanism for superconductivity suppression in
metallic AFs. The reason is that the sublattice-spin coupling in
the antiferromagnet gives the non-magnetic impurities an effec-
tive magnetic component. These effective magnetic impurities
are detrimental to superconductivity, except for spin-triplet
superconductivity with spin aligned orthogonal to the Néel
vector. As a result, dirty AFMs work as superconductivity fil-
ters letting only spin-triplet superconductivity with orthogonal
spin-projection to the Néel vector pass through. After studying
the critical temperature in SC/AFM bilayers, we show how the
superconducting correlations penetrate into the antiferromag-
netic metal, as well as the inverse proximity effect. Moreover,
we show how the long-range spin-triplet components can be
induced by either uncompensated or magnetic interfaces with
magnetic misalignment relative to the AFM Néel vector.
Theory: To study SC-AFM bilayers, we employ the quasi-
classical Keldysh formalism derived in [
33
]. It is valid under
the assumption that the Fermi wavelength is short compared to
the coherence length and the mean free path, and the chemical
potential,
𝜇
, is much larger than all other energy scales in the
system, except possibly the exchange energy between localized
spins and conducting electrons,
𝐽
. Note that
|𝐽/𝜇|<1
, since
|𝜇|=√𝐽2+𝑡2
, where
𝑡
is the hopping parameter evaluated at
the Fermi surface. We also assume the dirty limit, meaning
that the system is diffusive, and that there is no electromag-
netic vector potential. In this case, the quasiclassical Green’s
function ˇ𝑔solves [33]
𝑖∇ · ˇ
𝒋+𝜏𝑧(𝜀+𝑖𝛿) + ˆ
Δ+𝑖𝐽2
2𝜏imp 𝜇2𝜎𝑧𝜏𝑧ˇ𝑔𝜎𝑧𝜏𝑧,ˇ𝑔=0.(1)
Here,
ˇ
𝒋
is the matrix current,
𝜏𝑧
and
𝜎𝑧
are Pauli matrices
in Nambu- and spin-space, respectively,
𝜀
is energy,
𝛿
is the
Dynes parameter,
𝜏imp
is the elastic impurity scattering time
and
ˆ
Δ = Δ𝑖𝜏𝑦
, under the assumption that the gap parameter
Δ
is real. The spin-quantization axis is chosen to be parallel
arXiv:2210.09325v3 [cond-mat.supr-con] 28 May 2023