Three-Electrode Cell Calorimeter for Electrical Double Layer Capacitors
Three-Electrode Cell Calorimeter for Electrical Double Layer Capacitors
Joren E. Vos,1Hendrik P. Rodenburg,1Danny Inder Maur,1Ties J. W. Bakker,1Henkjan Siekman,2and Ben H.
Erné1
1)Van ’t Hoff Laboratory for Physical and Colloid Chemistry, Debye Institute for Nanomaterials Science, Utrecht University,
Padualaan 8, 3584 CH Utrecht, The Netherlands
2)Instrumentation Department, Utrecht University, Sorbonnelaan 4, 3584 CA Utrecht, The Netherlands
(Dated: 4 October 2022)
A calorimeter was built to measure the heat from a porous capacitive working electrode connected in a three-electrode
configuration. This makes it possible to detect differences between cathodic and anodic heat production. The elec-
trochemical cell contains a large electrolyte solution reservoir, ensuring a constant concentration of the salt solution
probed by the reference electrode via a Luggin tube. A heat flux sensor is used to detect the heat, and its calibration as a
gauge of the total amount of heat produced by the electrode is done on the basis of the net electrical work performed on
the working electrode during a full charging-discharging cycle. In principle, from the measured heat and the electrical
work, the change in internal energy of the working electrode can be determined as a function of applied potential. Such
measurements inform about the potential energy and average electric potential of ions inside the pores, giving insight
into the electrical double layer inside electrode micropores. Example measurements of the heat are shown for porous
carbon electrodes in aqueous salt solution.
I. INTRODUCTION
Capacitive porous electrodes are of interest for instance as
supercapacitors in power delivery systems1and as reversible
salt absorbants in water desalination.2During charging of a
porous electrode, electrical energy and ions are stored in the
electrical double layer (EDL). Experimental characterization
of the EDL helps to elucidate the energetic or ionic uptake ca-
pacity of the electrode. Changes in the amount of charge can
be measured in the external electrical circuit.3,4 Additional
information on the charging mechanism and the amounts of
ions inside the pores can for instance be obtained from in situ
NMR spectroscopy,5–8 infrared spectroscopy,9,10 and small-
angle neutron scattering.11,12 Here, we will focus on a thermo-
dynamic characterization approach that consists of measuring
the heat exchanged while the electrode is being charged or
discharged.
Electrodes in any electrochemical cell produce heat, al-
though this is generally not the intended outcome. One
example is heat generation during electrolysis reactions.13
Another is Joule heat produced by supercapacitors,14 which
can cause a strong temperature rise that can be damaging
for their performance.15–17 When it is possible to determine
the reversible heat, this provides valuable information on
the change in thermodynamic state of the system. The re-
versible heat can for example correspond to the change in
enthalpy of electrochemical reactions18,19 or to the entropic
heat from batteries, in agreement with the temperature de-
pendence of their open circuit voltage.20 For supercapacitors,
the reversible heat has been interpreted in different ways, as
the entropic heat from the confinement of ions into the pores
of the electrodes,21 or as changes in the entropic part of the
grand potential energy,22,23 or as due to several entropic and
enthalpic contributions because of mixing as well as electrical
and steric interactions of the ions,24–26 or as due to nonzero
potential energy of the ions in the pores.27
Measuring heat from porous electrodes requires a different
measurement approach than measuring heat from submono-
layer changes at a flat electrode,28 which result in very little
heat, produced very briefly.29 This requires highly sensitive
and rapid detection, which can for instance be achieved using
lithium tantalate-based sensors.30 Porous electrodes have a
much higher surface area and slow ionic transport in an ex-
tensive porous network,31,32 resulting in much more heat pro-
duction but spread out over a much longer time. Due to the
long duration of heat production, the measurement requires a
very stable background temperature to differentiate from heat
exchange due to temperature changes in the environment.
Here, a setup is presented that measures the heat of charg-
ing and discharging from a capacitive porous carbon33 elec-
trode, connected in a 3-electrode configuration. The setup
was first used in Ref. 27, where it was described much more
briefly. Earlier experiments on capacitive porous electrodes
were done on 2-electrode cells, by measuring the temper-
ature of the complete cell using a resistance temperature
detector,21,34 or by measuring the separate heats of both elec-
trodes, using heat flux sensors.25,35 When the heat of a com-
plete cell is measured, differences between cathodic and an-
odic heat production cannot be distinguished. This limitation
disappears when the heat of individual electrodes is measured.
However, when the cell has only two electrodes, even though
it is clear that the charge that exits one electrode enters the
other electrode, it is more difficult to clarify differences be-
tween cathodic and anodic behavior, because the potentials
applied to each electrode are not determined against a constant
reference. In the setup presented here, a reference electrode is
introduced as the third electrode. The current still flows from
the working electrode to a counter electrode, but the poten-
tial on the working electrode is applied and measured with
respect to an invariant reference electrode. A three-electrode
cell is commonly used in electrochemistry,36 but not for mea-
surements on commercial batteries or supercapacitors. In Sec-
tion II, the design and operation of the setup are presented, and
typical measurements are shown in Section III.
arXiv:2210.00980v1 [physics.ins-det] 3 Oct 2022