Spin current and chirality degrees of freedom inherent in localized electron orbitals
Shintaro Hoshino1, Michi-To Suzuki2,3, and Hiroaki Ikeda4
1Department of Physics, Saitama University, Sakura, Saitama 338-8570, Japan
2Center for Computational Materials Science, Institute for Materials Research,
Tohoku University, Sendai, Miyagi 980-8577, Japan
3Center for Spintronics Research Network, Graduate School of Engineering Science,
Osaka University, Toyonaka, Osaka 560-8531, Japan
4Department of Physics, Ritsumeikan University, Kusatsu, Shiga 525-8577, Japan
(Dated: October 6, 2022)
In solid state physics, any phase transition is commonly observed as a change in the microscopic
distribution of charge, spin, or current. Here we report the nature of an exotic order parameter inher-
ent in the localized electron orbitals that cannot be primarily captured by these three fundamental
quantities. This order parameter is described as the electric toroidal multipoles connecting differ-
ent total angular momenta under the spin-orbit coupling. The corresponding microscopic physical
quantity is the spin current tensor on an atomic scale, which induces spin-derived electric polariza-
tion and the chirality of the Dirac equation. We stress that the chirality intrinsic to the elementary
particle is the essence of electric toroidal multipoles. These findings link microscopic spin currents
and chirality in the Dirac theory to the concept of multipoles and provide a new perspective for
quantum states of matter.
Introduction.— In strongly correlated electron sys-
tems, the spin and orbital degrees of freedom of nearly lo-
calized electrons are activated by electronic correlations,
resulting in various intriguing phenomena, such as heavy
electrons, unconventional superconductivity, and exotic
magnetic orders. These quantum states are commonly
characterized by the spatial distribution of the funda-
mental microscopic physical quantities, charge, spin, and
current. They have been systematically studied using
the concept of multipole expansions [1–12]. These mul-
tipoles are classified into four categories (electric, mag-
netic, magnetic toroidal, and electric toroidal) according
to spatial parity and time-reversal parity [12]. Such a
classification is useful for elucidating exotic orders and
predicting novel response to external fields.
In particular, electric toroidal multipole ordering has
recently attracted much attention as novel nonmagnetic
degree of freedom [13–17] which has not been strongly
recognized so far. In localized electron systems, such
degrees of freedom are inherent in the components con-
necting different total angular momenta under the spin-
orbit coupling λ`·s. The simplest rank-1 electric toroidal
dipole is written as G(1) = `×s[15, 18–20]. When con-
sidering this electric toroidal dipole in analogy to a mag-
netic toroidal dipole [21], we would expect the electric
polarization to be circularly aligned. The ordinary elec-
tric polarization P(r) = rρ(r) (ρis a charge density),
however, cannot capture the toroidal structure, as P(r)
is a simple charge distribution. What physical quantity
characterizes the nature of electric toroidal multipoles
microscopically?
In the following, we clarify the underlying fundamental
physical quantity using the knowledge of the relativistic
quantum mechanics. It is shown that the electric polar-
ization PS(r) induced by the spin degrees of freedom is
responsible for the electric toroidal moment. The spin-
derived electric polarization PS(r) is also associated with
the microscopic spin current tensor, which is regarded as
one of the fundamental physical quantities analogous to
charge, spin, and electric current. The relation between
electric polarization and spin current has been discussed
in the context of spintronics based on weak-coupling itin-
erant Fermi liquid description [22]. We further find the
relation between the electric toroidal multipole, spin cur-
rent, and chirality of the Dirac equation by employing
the localized electron picture. This chirality degree of
freedom is intimately related to the diagonal part of the
spin current, and is a more fundamental quantity cor-
responding to electric toroidal multipoles. We thus link
microscopic spin currents and chirality in Dirac theory
to the concept of multipoles.
Definition of multipoles.— Let us start with the defini-
tion of multipoles in localized electron orbitals with the
angular momentum `. The multipole operators are de-
fined as a complete matrix basis set to describe all oper-
ators of the type c†
mσcm0σ0, where cmσ is the annihilation
operator of the electron with the magnetic quantum num-
ber m∈[−`, `] and spin σ=↑,↓. Under strong spin-orbit
coupling, the multipole operators are usually considered
only for a ground-state j=`±1/2 multiplet. We here
consider the full space containing different jmultiplets.
The classification scheme recently formulated for `= 1
case [20] is applied to the general `[23]. In this case, the
generic rank-pmultipole is written as
Xγ(pη) = X
mm0σσ0
c†
mσOγ
mσ,m0σ0(pη)cm0σ0,(1)
where p= 0,··· ,2`+1, and Ois a matrix representation
of the multipole. γis a label to distinguish 2p+ 1 de-
generacies. We have separated the rank-pmultipole into
several pieces denoted by the η-index: η=a, b denote
intra-jmultiplet component, and η=c, d corresponds to
a component connecting different jmultiplet [24]. For
η=a, b, c, the even (p= 2q) or odd (p= 2q+ 1) rank
arXiv:2210.02148v1 [cond-mat.str-el] 5 Oct 2022