Numerical Evaluation of a Soliton Pair with Long
Range Interaction
Joachim Wabnig, Josef Resch, Dominik Theuerkauf,
Fabian Anmasser and Manfried Faber
October 25, 2022
Abstract
Within the model of topological particles (MTP) we determine the interaction energy of
monopole pairs, sources and sinks of a Coulombic field. The monopoles are represented by
topological solitons of finite size and mass, described by a field without any divergences. We
fix the soliton centres in numerical calculations at varying distance. Due to the finite size of
the solitons we get deviations from the Coulomb potential at distances of a few soliton radii.
We compare the numerical results for these deviations with the running of the coupling in
perturbative QED.
1 Introduction
In Refs. [1,2] we proposed a dynamical model for monopoles without any singularities, the model
of topological particles (MTP). Particles are identified by topological quantum numbers, masses of
particles originate in field energy, charges show Coulombic behaviour and are quantised in units of
an elementary charge. Depending on the interpretation, charges can be either electric or magnetic.
The model and its many predictions were extensively discussed in Refs. [2].
Magnetic monopoles were invented by Dirac in 1931 [3,4] as quantised singularities in the elec-
tromagnetic field. He found that their existence would explain the quantisation of electric charge,
proven in Millikan’s experiments [5] but not explained by Maxwell theory [6]. Dirac monopoles
have two types of singularities, the Dirac string, a line-like singularity connecting monopoles and
antimonopoles, and the singularity in the centre of the monopole, a singularity analogous to the sin-
gularity of point-like electrons. Wu and Yang succeeded to formulate magnetic monopoles without
the line-like singularities of the Dirac strings by using either a fibre-bundle construction with two
different gauge fields [7], one for the northern and one for the southern hemisphere of the monopole,
or by a non-abelian SU(2) gauge field in 3+1D [8,9]. These Wu-Yang monopoles still suffer from
the point-like singularities in the centre. There are monopole solutions without any singularity
in the Georgi-Glashow model [10], the ’tHooft-Polyakov monopoles [11,12]. The Georgi-Glashow
model, formulated in 3+1D, has 15 degrees of freedom, an adjoint Higgs field with three degrees
of freedom and an SU(2) gauge field with 4·3 = 12 field components. Only one degree of freedom
is needed for the Sine-Gordon model [13], a model in 1+1D. It is most interesting that in addition
to waves, it has kink and anti-kink solutions which interact with each other. The kink-antikink
configurations are attracting and the kink-kink configurations repelling. The simplicity of the Sine-
Gordon model inspired Skyrme [14,15,16,17] to a model in 3+1D with a scalar SU(2)-valued field,
i.e. three degrees of freedom. Stable topological solitons (Skyrmions) emerge in that model with
the properties of particles, interacting at short range. MTP was inspired by the simplicity and
physical content of the Sine-Gordon model, it was first formulated in [1]. It has the same degrees
of freedom as the Skyrme model, but uses a different Lagrangian. Its relations to electrodynamics
and symmetry breaking were discussed in [2,18,19,20].
In this article, we want to concentrate on numerical determinations of the interaction energy for
a pair of charges, represented by a soliton-antisoliton pair. Due to the non-existence of magnetic
monopoles, comparisons to nature are possible only for electric charges and the predictions of QED.
In Sect. 2we repeat the formulation and some basic properties of the model, in Sect. 3we
present the numerical formulation in cylindrical coordinates and in Sect. 4we show first results of
the calculations and compare the results to perturbative QED.
1
arXiv:2210.13374v1 [hep-lat] 24 Oct 2022