Non-Markovianity through entropy-based quantum thermodynamics
J. M. Z. Choquehuanca,1F. M. de Paula,2and M. S. Sarandy1
1Instituto de F´ısica, Universidade Federal Fluminense,
Av. Gal. Milton Tavares de Souza s/n, Gragoat´a, 24210-346, Niter´oi, RJ, Brazil
2Centro de Ciˆencias Naturais e Humanas, Universidade Federal do ABC,
Avenida dos Estados 5001, 09210-580, Santo Andr´e, SP, Brazil
(Dated: March 28, 2023)
We introduce a generalized approach to characterize the non-Markovianity of quantum dynamical maps via
breakdown of monotonicity of thermodynamic functions. By adopting an entropy-based formulation of quantum
thermodynamics, we use the relationship between heat and entropy to propose a measure of non-Markovianity
based on the heat flow for single-qubit quantum evolutions. This measure can be applied for unital dynamical
maps that do not invert the sign of the internal energy. Under certain conditions, it can also be extended for other
thermodynamic functions, such as internal energy and work flows. In this context, a natural connection between
heat and quantum coherence can be identified for dynamical maps that are both unital and incoherent. As appli-
cations, we explore dissipative and non-dissipative quantum dynamical processes, illustrating the compatibility
between our thermodynamic quantifiers and the well-establish measure defined via quantum coherence.
I. INTRODUCTION
Quantum thermodynamics [1, 2] is a research field in the
making, with fruitful conceptual implications and a potential
range of applications, mainly in the field of quantum tech-
nologies (see, e.g., Ref. [3]). It aims at generalizing the laws
of thermodynamics to the quantum domain, rewriting thermo-
dynamic state functions and processes from the bottom up so
that the laws of thermodynamics can be consistently applied
to small systems and scaled up to the classical world [4–9].
Remarkably, the definition of thermodynamic variables, such
as work and heat, has been challenging, since they cannot be
taken as observables described by Hermitian operators [10].
In the standard framework of quantum thermodynamics [11],
the internal energy change due to state population rearrange-
ment induced by the external environment has been defined
as heat. On the other hand, the internal energy change due
to energy gap variations induced by the coherent dynamics
has been defined as work. This framework has recently been
revisited through an entropy-based formulation for heat and
work [12–14], with heat identified as the entropy-related con-
tribution to the internal energy change and work taken as the
part unrelated to the entropy change. In particular, this has
been applied to the study of the thermodynamics of a single
qubit far from equilibrium [15], where a notion of temperature
compatible with the classical limit is introduced. The alter-
native entropy-based view turns out to motivate an interplay
with quantum information, with the interpretation of thermo-
dynamic variables in terms of resources and correlations in a
quantum system.
Indeed, quantum thermodynamics is intrinsically connected
with quantum information theory, with quantum resources
strongly affecting thermodynamic variables and processes.
This is manifested in a number of situations, such as mea-
surements and their influence on the work performed on/by
a quantum system [10, 16–19], efficiency of thermodynamic
tasks in quantum correlated devices [6, 20–22], coherence ef-
fects on work and heat [23–30], among others. By looking
at information-based quantifiers, it is known that quantum co-
herence plays a relevant role in the characterization of system-
bath memory effects. In particular, quantum coherence can be
associated with a measure of non-Markovianity for incoherent
dynamical maps [31–34]. Notice that a memoriless (Marko-
vian) behavior is always an idealization, with non-Markovian
quantum dynamics being non-negligible in a number of differ-
ent scenarios (see, e.g., Refs. [35–37]). From an applied point
of view, non-Markovian dynamics may be also a resource for
certain quantum tasks [38, 39].
In this work, we adopt the entropy-based formulation of
quantum thermodynamics to introduce a measure of non-
Markovianity based on the heat flow for single-qubit quan-
tum evolutions. This measure can be applied for unital dy-
namical maps that do not invert the sign of the internal en-
ergy (energy sign-preserving maps), which is rooted in the
idea that von Neumann entropy itself can be used to build a
non-Markovianity measure for unital maps [40]. Under cer-
tain conditions, we can also extend this approach to other
thermodynamic functions, such as internal energy and work
flows. Then, a natural connection between heat and quan-
tum coherence can be observed for dynamical maps that are
both unital and incoherent. In particular, we show that heat
and work are monotonically related to quantum coherence for
non-dissipative processes. Consequently, both heat and work
can witness non-Markovianity for non-dissipative unital maps
as well as non-dissipative incoherent maps. Moreover, we es-
tablish and illustrate the conditions over the system purity and
the Hamiltonian such that the thermodynamic variables can
be used to provide non-Markovianity measures throughout the
evolution in a decohering environment.
The paper is organized as follows. In Section II, we briefly
introduce the entropy-based formulation of quantum thermo-
dynamics, expressing the first law of thermodynamics and its
corresponding thermodynamic variables for a single qubit sys-
tem. In section III, we discuss the non-Markovian dynamics,
where we propose measures of non-Markovianity via general-
ized sign-preserving functions. In the section IV, we consider
applications in dissipative and non-dissipative evolutions, il-
lustrating the use of thermodynamic variables as measures of
non-Markovianity. In section V, we present our conclusions.
arXiv:2210.03767v2 [quant-ph] 27 Mar 2023