
Neutrino magnetohydrodynamic instabilities in presence of two-flavor oscillations
Debjani Chatterjee,1, ∗Amar P. Misra,2, †and Samiran Ghosh1, ‡
1Department of Applied Mathematics, University of Calcutta, Kolkata 700 009, India
2Department of Mathematics, Siksha Bhavana, Visva-Bharati University, Santiniketan-731 235, India
The influence of neutrino flavor oscillations on the propagation of magnetohydrodynamic (MHD)
waves and instabilities is studied in neutrino-beam driven magnetoplasmas. Using the neutrino
MHD model, a general dispersion relation is derived which manifests the resonant interactions of
MHD waves, not only with the neutrino beam, but also with the neutrino flavor oscillations. It is
found that the latter contribute to the wave dispersion and enhance the magnitude of the instability
of oblique magnetosonic waves. However, the shear-Alfv´en wave remains unaffected by the neutrino
beam and neutrino flavor oscillations. Such an enhancement of the magnitude of the instability of
magnetosonic waves can be significant for relatively long-wavelength perturbations in the regimes
of high neutrino number density and/or strong magnetic field, giving a convincing mechanism for
type-II core-collapse supernova explosion.
I. INTRODUCTION
Neutrinos are generally produced due to very high ex-
plosions in the core of massive stars and can have signif-
icant impact on the cooling of white dwarfs and neutron
stars [1, 2]. The most apparent source of neutrinos is the
Sun, where they are produced due to the simplest nuclear
fusion reaction in which two protons combine to form a
deuterium nucleus with the emission of a positron and a
neutrino. All other complex reaction processes that lead
to heavier elements can also produce neutrinos which get
away from the Sun at the speed of light in vacuum. Neu-
trinos are also produced by cosmic rays hitting up nu-
clei in the Earth’s atmosphere, similar to the reactions
of terrestrial high-energy particle accelerators. Such nu-
clear reactions result not only in electron neutrinos as
in the Sun, but also in two other flavors, namely, muon
neutrinos and tau neutrinos–all of which were detected
by super-Kamiokande detector [3]. On the other hand,
the neutrino-producing fusion reactions in stars do not
release energy in the form of light or heat that could pro-
vide pressure to stop gravitational collapse of the stellar
core. So, the collapse occurs and it continues until the
density in a nucleus is close to that in the core and sud-
denly a massive explosion occurs in producing all flavors
of neutrinos. Such a sudden and higher optical gleam is
known as a core-collapse supernova, e.g., SN1987A [4].
Although the interaction between neutrinos and matter
is weak, in the gamma-ray bursts of a supernova explo-
sion, the energy emitted from neutrinos can be very high
(almost 99% of the gravitational binding energy of col-
lapsing stars) and the intensity can be more than 1028
W cm−2. Furthermore, in the first few seconds of explo-
sion, the neutrino burst that originates from the core of
supernova is a source of free energy to drive collective os-
cillations and instabilities which may lead to the revival
∗chatterjee.debjani10@gmail.com
†apmisra@visva-bharati.ac.in; apmisra@gmail.com
‡sran g@yahoo.com
of a stalled supernova shock [5, 6]. Typically, neutrinos
produced in the solar atmosphere or in the core-collapse
of stars have energies ranging from 1 to 30 MeV. How-
ever, recent observations with IceCube data have indi-
cated that neutrinos can have energies more or less 1015
eV [3, 7]. Such high-energy neutrinos are expected to be
produced in astrophysical objects via the interactions of
highly relativistic charged particles (Cosmic rays) with
either target particles or photons [3].
Neutrinos produced from different sources can play sig-
nificant roles in the formation of galaxies, galaxy clusters,
and various coherent structures at large scales. Apart
from their possible gravitational interactions, neutrinos
interact weakly with matter and thus are very impor-
tant in astrophysics. In regions where other particles get
trapped or move through slow diffusion processes, neutri-
nos can still escape from them and thus connect those of
matter without being detached from each other. In very
hot or dense astrophysical objects, the emission of neu-
trinos can be an important energy-loss mechanism. The
energy transfer rate can be faster and very efficient since
neutrinos have almost zero mass and can travel at rel-
ativistic speeds. Furthermore, since neutrinos produced
in the Sun can be detected at the Earth, they are use-
ful to study nuclear reactions that can occur in the core
of massive stars. Also, because neutrinos are electrically
neutral like photons and hence uninfluenced by the strong
magnetic fields, they tend to move back to the creation
regions, and thus can provide useful information about
the regions where particle creation and acceleration take
place in the Universe. For more information about roles
of neutrinos, see, e.g., [8].
In stellar environments, the collective plasma effects
can remarkably modify the production rate of neutrinos,
e.g., the decay of photons and plasmons into neutrino
pairs, which is the dominant neutrino emission mech-
anism at high-density plasmas. The neutrino emission
can also be possible in dense hot matter due to electron-
positron annihilation [9], in ultra-relativistic plasmas due
to positron and plasmino annihilation [10]. The neutrinos
interacting with plasmas play key roles in many astro-
physical situations including supernova explosions. Such
arXiv:2210.09590v2 [physics.plasm-ph] 4 Mar 2023