
Schwinger model at θ=π
1. Introductory comments
Topological terms are an interesting ingredient in quantum field theories, as they may alter the
symmetry content of a theory in a non-local way. This non-local character implies that a non-
perturbative regularization has to be used. An interesting non-perturbative regularization is the
lattice, which, however, poses two challenges: a suitable discretization of the topological charge,
and a way to overcome the complex action problem that is caused by the topological term.
In recent work [1] it was shown that a generalization of the Villain action [2] gives rise to an
integer-valued definition of the topological charge in terms of the Villain variables. As a conse-
quence, charge conjugation (C) symmetry at θ=πis implemented exactly and its spontaneous
breaking was studied in gauge Higgs models [3,4], while a study of C symmetry breaking in the
same model but with Wilson gauge action and a field theoretic non-integer definition of the topo-
logical charge led to less conclusive results [5,6]. We remark that also the Atiyah Singer index
theorem [7] is relevant for the physics of the fermionic system studied here, which emerges in the
continuum limit of the Villain formulation [8]. Generalized Villain formulations were also used to
map the gauged XY model in the strong coupling limit at θ=πto the Ising model [9], to construct
a lattice discretization for fracton theories [10] and to explore non-invertible duality defects [11].
As was already mentioned, the topological term also generates a complex action problem,
which, however, may be solved by switching to a worldline/worldsheet representation [3,4] that
can be simulated efficiently [12,13]. For fermions there is also a potential sign problem coming
from the Grassmann nature of the fermionic variables and the γ-algebra. For the case of massless
staggered fermions in 2d, i.e., the discretization we use here, the sign problem is known to be absent
[14,15], and also the quartic fermion self interaction does not alter this result.
The ingredients outlined in the last two paragraphs, i.e., the integer-valued Villain-based defi-
nition of the topological charge, the worldline/worldsheet representation for overcoming the com-
plex action problem and the absence of a fermionic sign problem for massless staggered fermions
in 2d allow one for the first time to study the spontaneous breaking of charge conjugation in a
fermionic system: The 2d massless Schwinger model with a quartic self interaction and a topolog-
ical term at θ=π. Charge conjugation appears as a Z2symmetry and we explore whether it can
be broken spontaneously as a function of the quartic coupling parameter J.
Using Monte Carlo simulations of the system in its worldline/worldsheet representation we
study various bulk quantities, in particular the C symmetry breaking topological charge density hqi
and the corresponding susceptibility. For weak coupling Jthe symmetry remains unbroken, while
at strong coupling we observe breaking of C symmetry. We find strong evidence for a critical point
near J∼0.9, which seems compatible with the 2d Ising universality class as expected. Varying θ
in the strong coupling phase we observe a first order jump in the order parameter hqiwhen crossing
θ=π, which is a further indication that the system implements the 2d Ising phenomenology.
2. The Schwinger Model and its worldline/worldsheet representation
The partition sum of our model is given by,
Z=ZD[A]ZDψ,ψBβ,θ[A]e−SFψ,ψ,A,(2.1)
1