
Field Induced Multiple Superconducting Phases in UTe2along Hard Magnetic Axis
H. Sakai,1, ∗Y. Tokiwa,1P. Opletal,1M. Kimata,2S. Awaji,3
T. Sasaki,3D. Aoki,4S. Kambe,1Y. Tokunaga,1and Y. Haga1
1Advanced Science Research Center, Japan Atomic Energy Agency, Tokai, Ibaraki 319-1195, Japan
2Institute for Materials Research, Tohoku University, Sendai, Miyagi, 980-8577, Japan
3Institute for Materials Research, Tohoku University, Katahira 2-1-1, Sendai 980-8577, Japan
4Institute for Materials Research, Tohoku University, Oarai, Ibaraki 311-1313, Japan
(Dated: December 21, 2022)
The superconducting (SC) phase diagram in uranium ditelluride is explored under magnetic fields
(H) along the hard magnetic b-axis using a high-quality single crystal with Tc= 2.1 K. Simultaneous
electrical resistivity and AC magnetic susceptibility measurements discern low- and high-field SC
(LFSC and HFSC, respectively) phases with contrasting field-angular dependence. Crystal quality
increases the upper critical field of the LFSC phase, but the H∗of ∼15 T, at which the HFSC
phase appears, is always the same through the various crystals. A phase boundary signature is also
observed inside the LFSC phase near H∗, indicating an intermediate SC phase characterized by
small flux pinning forces.
Uranium ditelluride (UTe2) has attracted considerable
attention as a strong candidate for spin-triplet and topo-
logical superconductivity. Ran et al. [1] initially reported
unconventional superconductivity of this compound with
a superconducting (SC) transition temperature (Tc) of
1.6 K and vast upper critical field (Hc2) that exceeds the
Pauli-limiting field. Slight decreases in the nuclear mag-
netic resonance (NMR) shift strongly suggest the spin-
triplet SC pairing under ambient pressure [2–4]. Mean-
while, the discovery of multiple SC phases under pressure
further supports spin-triplet formation with spin-degrees
of freedom [5–8]. The topological aspect of the SC state
is experimentally suggested through scanning tunneling
microscopy [9], polar Kerr effect [10], and London pene-
tration depth [11] measurements.
UTe2crystallizes in a body-centered orthorhombic
structure (Immm) [12, 13]. Magnetic-field-reinforced su-
perconductivity, an extraordinary phenomenon in UTe2,
appears when a magnetic field (H) is applied along the
crystallographic b-axis, which is perpendicular to the easy
magnetic a-axis, along which uranium 5fspin moments
favor aligning with an Ising character [14–18]. In Hkb,
Tcinitially decreases with increasing H, and then starts
to increase above µ0H∗'15 T, i.e., a characteristic ‘L’-
shape Hc2(T) appears. Superconductivity persists up to
a metamagnetic transition at µ0Hm'34.5 T and sud-
denly disappears above Hm.
Previously, one might assume a uniform SC state was
realized in UTe2below the L-shape Hc2(T) because an
internal transition could not be found. However, two
discernible SC phases in the case of Hkbare reported by
specific heat measurement using a crystal with Tc= 1.85
K in the case of Hkb[19], which is also detected by AC
magnetic susceptibility (χAC) for a crystal of Tc= 1.85
K [20]. Remarkably, a second-order phase transition is
observed inside the SC state, which separates the low-
and high-field SC (LFSC and HFSC, respectively) phases
with µ0H∗'15 T. As a thermodynamic consideration
[21], however, three second-order transition lines cannot
meet at a single point unless another line emerges from
here. These results motivate us to continue the studies
using a higher-quality single crystal.
The SC properties of UTe2clearly depend on the sam-
ple quality. Since impurity effects are completely un-
known in rare spin-triplet SC cases, it is exceptionally
necessary to remove defects as much as possible. Al-
though growth condition optimization using a chemical
vapor transport (CVT) method increased Tcup to 2
K and the residual resistivity ratio (RRR) up to ∼88
[22, 23], CVT crystals still contain a small number of
uranium vacancies within 1% –even in high Tccrystals
[24, 25]. Recently, UTe2crystals higher Tcof 2.1 K and
larger RRRs far over 100 have been grown using the
molten salt flux (MSF) method [26]. Successful detection
of de Haas–van Alphen oscillation signals [27] guarantees
the crystals of high quality with a long mean free path
and lower impurity scatterings. In this letter, we explore
the SC phase diagram of such an ultla-clean UTe2crys-
tal obtained by the MSF growth to search for a missing
phase line inside of the SC state. For this purpose, the
electrical resistivity (ρ) and change of χAC were in situ
measured simultaneously on an identical crystal.
Figure S2(a) schematically illustrates the experimen-
tal setup of this study. A crystal was selected with
a size of 0.73 ×0.75 ×4.6 mm3and RRR=180. The
crystal was mounted on a two-axis goniostage, and the
probe was inserted into a 3He cryostat. ρ(T, H) was
measured using the AC four-probe method with a cur-
rent of 0.3 mA. The resonance frequency of the LC cir-
cuit is νTune = (2π√LC)−1, where Land Care the
inductance and capacitance, respectively. If χAC is re-
duced due to SC diamagnetism, L=L0(1 + χAC) de-
creases, where is a filling factor of the sample to the
coil. Consequently, the onset Tcwas detected as a kink
in ∆νTune = (νTune −ν0)/ν0∝1/√∆χAC. Here, we set
ν0'3.7 MHz by tuning the variable capacitors shown
arXiv:2210.05909v2 [cond-mat.supr-con] 20 Dec 2022