
with the Federation Council. It was unusual for a human being to be so massive in size, but the admiral
reportedly had both a rare chaotic metabolic disorder and a great love of food. He was a remarkable
man, Data thought, recalling what he had read about Pietro Barbieri in the records: the admiral had
earned a degree in astrophysics at fifteen, had been one of Starfleet Academy’s most brilliant students
after that, and had spent twenty years as a starship captain, when his incurable metabolic ailment and
increasing corpulence had made a life aboard ship as an active officer impossible. From what Data knew
about Admiral Barbieri, he spent almost all of his time thinking, but clearly the admiral had not had much
time to think about this nova.
“TheEnterprise,” Barbieri continued, “was the only vessel close enough to get to Epic Three within a
week. There’s no chance of routing additional Starfleet vessels to you in time to help out.” An uneasy
look passed across his round face, as if he were feeling the emotion called shame. Perhaps he was
ashamed, given that he had so little advice to offer. Starfleet and the Council depended upon the admiral
as they would a natural resource. If a problem seemed intractable, it was said, ask Pietro Barbieri. He
was capable of vast intuitive leaps—many of them illogical, of course, but always interesting as
hypothetical proposals that were often justified much later. It was said that Barbieri prided himself on
being able to help guide Federation Council decisions with his intuition and intellect alone, although Data
suspected that this widespread assumption was inaccurate. The admiral was, after all, only one individual.
Many others also advised the Council, and perhaps the admiral had simply accumulated credit for the
results of larger brain-storming efforts.
“But now that we’re here,” Picard asked from behind Data, “exactly what can we do?” Data glanced
back for a moment to see the captain lean forward slightly in his station chair. “It’s impossible to move
twenty million people in so short a period. We couldn’t even begin to set up our transporters to beam up
and temporarily store that many people in a week’s time. Even if we had the time, no one has ever tried
such a procedure on that large a scale. The error rate would be enormous.”
Data knew that this was so, and that only lip service would be devoted to this illusory possibility.
Glancing aft, he could see Lieutenant Commander Geordi La Forge, who was sitting at his engineering
station, nodding in agreement with Miles O’Brien, the transporter chief, who was at mission operations.
Interesting as it was to speculate about such a transporter feat, it was far beyond what could be done
reliably within a week. To place that many people safely in the transporter’s pattern buffer, assuming that
the extensive modifications to make that possible could be made quickly, would require that a beam
operate day and night for months. Quantum errors would make a substantial loss of the human data
inevitable. Even if those losses were accepted, the power and a sufficiently detailed program were just
not there, leaving aside the problem of exactly where such a vast block of human information could be
rematerialized in time to prevent deterioration.
“You’re quite right, Captain.” Barbieri’s jowls trembled as he shook his head. “There’s no way out of it.
When the time comes, you may have to settle for taking the few people you can, along with one or two
cultural treasures. You’ll just have to assess the situation personally and decide what is to be done.
That’s all I can tell you. We cannot leave this world to its fate without some demonstration of concern
and an effort to help, however futile.” The admiral grimaced. “There has to be a presence, so that other
Federation worlds will know that we tried, that the people of Epictetus Three were not completely
abandoned.”
Admiral Barbieri was correct, Data concluded, given what they knew so far; the situation seemed
intractable, perhaps even truly hopeless. But Data also concluded that no one yet had all the facts about
the threat to Epictetus III. And where there seemed to be a poverty of both facts and assumptions, there
might also be alternatives.