
to"—and his sweetness of character; but it struck Kirkthat they were almost elbowing each other aside to
praisehim, and that they were in an unprecedented hurry toget back to their own cramped ship, without
even somuch as begging a bottle of brandy.
Charlie's curiosity had certainly been obvious fromthose first moments, though he showed some trepida
tion, too—which was not surprising, considering his longand lonely exile. Kirk assigned Yeoman Rand to
takehim to his quarters. It was at this point that Charliestunned her and everyone else present by asking
Kirkhonestly:
"Is that a girl?"
Leonard McCoy, the ship's surgeon, checked Charliefrom top to toe and found him in excellent physical
condition: no traces of malnutrition, of exposure, of hard-ship of any sort; truly remarkable for a boy
who'd hadto fend for himself on a strange world from the age ofthree. On the other hand, it was
reasonable to supposethat fourteen years later, Charlie would either be ingood shape, or dead; he would
have had to come toterms with his environment within the first few years.
Charlie was not very communicative about this puz-zle, though he asked plenty of questions himself—he
seemed earnestly to want to know all the right thingsto do, and even more urgently, to be liked, but the
purport of some of McCoy's questions apparently baffledhim.
No, nobody had survived the crash. He had learnedEnglish by talking to the memory banks on the ship;
they still worked. No, the Thasians hadn't helped him;there were no Thasians. At first he had eaten stores
from the wreck; then he had found some other... things,growing around.
Charlie then asked to see the ship's rule book. On theAntares,he said, he hadn't done or said all the right
things. When that happened, people got angry; he gotangry, too. He didn't like making the same mistake
twice.
"I feel the same way," McCoy told him. "But youcan't rush such matters. Just keep your eyes open, and
when in doubt, smile and say nothing. It works verynicely."
Charlie returned McCoy's grin, and McCoy dismissed him with a swat on the rump, to Charlie's obvious
aston-ishment.
McCoy brought the problem up again on the bridgewith Kirk and his second-in-command, Mr. Spock.
Yeoman Rand was there working on a duty roster, and atonce volunteered to leave; but since she had
seen asmuch of Charlie as anyone had, Kirk asked her to stay.Besides, Kirk was fond of her, though he
fondly imagined that to be a secret even from her.
"Earth history is full of cases where a small childmanaged to survive in a wilderness," McCoy went on.
"I've read some of your legends," said Spock, who wasnative to a nonsolar planet confusingly called
Vulcan."They all seem to require a wolf to look after theinfants."
"What reason would the boy have to lie, if therewere Thasians?"
"Nevertheless there's some evidence that there were,at least millennia ago," Spock said. "The first survey
reported some highly sophisticated artifacts. And condi-tions haven't changed on Thasus for at least three
millionyears. There might well besome survivors."