
in futile anger. Somewhere among it all were the skeletons of the thousands who had died, of all ages and
both sexes. Their skully sightlessness, for all he knew, was turning empty, curse-torn eye holes at him.
The stench had long since gone from the desert, and the lizards held their lairs untroubled. No man
approached the fenced-off burial ground where what remained of bodies lay in the gashed crater carved out
in that final fall.
Only Plat came. He returned year after year and always, as though to ward off so many Evil Eyes, he
took his gold medal with him. It hung suspended bravely from his neck as he stood on the crest. On it was
inscribed simply, “To the Liberator!”
This time, Fulton was with him. Fulton had been a Lower One once in the days before the crash; the
days when there had been Higher Ones and Lower Ones.
Fulton said, “I am amazed you insist on coming here, Philo.”
Plat said, “I must. You know the sound of the crash was heard for hundreds of miles; seismographs
registered it around the world. My ship was almost directly above it; the shock vibrations caught me and
flung me miles. Yet all I can remember of sound is that one composite scream as Atlantis began its fall.”
“It had to be done.”
“Words,” sighed Plat. “There were babies and guiltless ones.”
“No one is guiltless.”
“Nor am I. Ought I to have been the executioner?”
“Someone had to be.” Fulton was firm. ’Consider the world now, twenty-five years later. Democracy
re-established, education once more universal, culture available for the masses, and science once more
advancing. Two expeditions have already landed on Mars.”
“I know. I know. But that, too, was a culture. THC called it Atlantis because it was an island that ruled
the world. It was an island in the sky, not the sea. It was a city and a world all at once, Fulton. You never saw
its crystal covering and its gorgeous buildings. It was a single jewel carved of stone and metal. It was a
dream.”
“It was concentrated happiness distilled out of the little supply distributed to billions of ordinary folk
who lived on the Surface.”
“Yes, you are right. Yes, it had to be. But it might have been so different, Fulton. You know,” he seated
himself on the hard rock, crossed his arms upon his knees and cradled his chin in them, “I think, sometimes,
of how it must have been in the old days, when there were nations and wars upon the Earth. I think of how
much a miracle it must have seemed to the peoples when the United Nations first became a real world
government, and what Atlantis must have meant to them.
“It was a capital city that governed Earth but was not of it. It was a black disc in the air, capable of
appearing anywhere on Earth at any height; belonging to no one nation, but to all the planet; the product of
no one nation’s ingenuity but the first great achievement of all the race - and then, what it became!”
Fulton said, “Shall we go? We’ll want to get back to the ship before dark.”
Plat went on, “In a way. I suppose it was inevitable. The human race never did invent an institution that
didn’t end as a cancer. Probably in prehistoric times, the medicine man who began as the repository of tribal
wisdom ended as the last bar to tribal advance. In ancient Rome, the citizen army -”
Fulton was letting him speak - patiently. It was a queer echo of the past. And there had been other eyes
upon him in those days, patiently waiting, while he talked.
“- the citizen army that defended the Romans against all comers from Veii to Carthage, became the
professional Praetorian Guard that sold the Imperium and levied tribute on all the Empire. The Turks
developed the Janissaries as their invincible advance guard against Europe and the Sultan ended as a slave
of his Janissary slaves. The barons of medieval Europe protected the serfs against the Northmen and the
Magyars, then remained six hundred years longer as a parasite aristocracy that contributed nothing.”
Plat became aware of the patient eyes and said, “Don’t you understand me?”
One of the bolder technicians said, “With your kind permission, Higher One, we must needs be at
work.”
“Yes, I suppose you must.”
The technician felt sorry. This Higher One was queer, but he meant well. Though he spoke a deal of
nonsense, he inquired after their families, told them they were fine fellows, and that their work made them
better than the Higher Ones.
So he explained, “You see, there is another shipment of granite and steel for the new theater and we will
have to shift the energy distribution. It is becoming very hard to do that. The Higher Ones will not listen.”
“Now that’s what I mean. You should make them listen.”
But they just stared at him, and at that moment an idea crawled gently into Plat’s unconscious mind.