2
which has attracted extensive attention [22]–[25]. The authors
of [22] reused the communication signals for carrying out
target sensing and investigated the sensing and communica-
tion (S&C) tradeoff under several design criteria of sensing
beampattern. To achieve the full degrees-of-freedom (DoFs) of
sensing, the authors of [23] proposed to exploit the composite
transmit signal, where an additional dedicated sensing signal is
added together with the communication signals. It was shown
that the composite transmit signal is capable of achieving bet-
ter sensing beampattern than the communication-only signal.
As a further advance, a flexible beamforming approach is
proposed in [24] for guaranteeing the desired levels of S&C
performance. Furthermore, the authors of [25] developed a
holographic beamforming scheme that employs more densely
deployed radiation elements in an antenna array to realize finer
controllability of the S&C beams. However, only considering
the waveform design at the transmitter cannot catch the overall
sensing performance. As such, some works also considered
the sensing performance metrics at the receiver [26]–[28].
Specifically, the authors of [26] jointly optimized the transmit
waveform and the filter at the receiver to maximize the signal-
to-interference-plus-noise ratio (SINR) of the sensing echo
signal. To characterize the parameter estimation accuracy at
the receiver, the fundamental Cram´
er-Rao bound (CRB) was
exploited as the sensing performance metric in [27] and [28].
Most recently, there are growing research contributions to the
new modulation techniques for ISAC. For example, the authors
of [29] conceived an ISAC framework based on the orthogonal
time frequency space (OTFS) modulation technique. In OTFS,
the communication symbols are multiplexed in the delay-
Doppler domain, which well matches the parameter estima-
tion in the sensing function. Moreover, the authors of [30]
proposed a novel delay alignment modulation (DAM)-aided
ISAC framework to guarantee high Doppler shift tolerance
and low peak-to-average-power ratio (PAPR).
B. Motivations and Contributions
As mentioned above, full-duplex communication has been
studied in diverse scenarios, but there is still a paucity of
research contributions on integrating the sensing function into
full-duplex communication systems. It is well known that
compared with half-duplex mode, full-duplex mode can almost
double the communication capacity by utilizing advanced SI
cancellation techniques. However, we note that in full-duplex
communication systems, the SI consists of two components,
namely direct-path interference and reflected-path interference
[4]. When integrating the sensing function into the full-duplex
communication systems, the reflected-path interference cannot
be totally eliminated since it also includes the useful sensing
echo signal reflected by the target of interest. In other words,
part of the SI, i.e., the sensing echo signal, needs to be
preserved to guarantee the sensing performance. In this case,
an interesting question arises, does full-duplex mode with the
preserved sensing echo signal still outperform half-duplex
mode?
To answer this question, we propose to integrate the sensing
function into the classical bidirectional communication system
[4], [14], which is referred to as a bidirectional ISAC system.
In this system, a pair of dual-functional transceivers carry
out two-way communication and mutual sensing. Then, we
investigate the full-duplex and half-duplex operations for the
bidirectional ISAC system in both narrowband and wide-
band scenarios. The corresponding transmit beamforming is
optimized for characterizing S&C tradeoff regions achieved
by both full-duplex and half-duplex operations, which are
compared to provide answers to the raised question. It is
suggested that full-duplex mode may not always outperform
half-duplex mode.
The primary contributions of this paper are as follows:
•We propose a bidirectional ISAC system, where a pair
of transceivers communicate with each other and sense
each other’s direction. Then, we design the corresponding
full-duplex and half-duplex operation protocols, which
are distinguished by whether the communication signals
are transmitted and received at the same time or not,
for both narrowband and wideband systems. Based on
these protocols, we further study the S&C tradeoff by
optimizing the transmit beamforming.
•For the narrowband system, we redesign the conven-
tional full-duplex and half-duplex operations for the
bidirectional ISAC system. Then, for both operations,
we formulate a joint beamforming optimization problem
for maximizing the weighted sum of the communication
achievable rate and the sensing CRB, which characterizes
the S&C tradeoff. To solve it, we develop a one-layer
successive convex approximation (SCA)-based algorithm
to obtain Karush-Kuhn-Tucker (KKT) optimal solutions.
•For the wideband system, we propose the new full-
duplex and half-duplex operation protocols by exploiting
different delays in communication and sensing echo sig-
nals. Moreover, the DAM technique is used to address
frequency-selective communication channels based on
delay pre-compensation and path-based beamforming.
Furthermore, we redesign the proposed SCA-based al-
gorithm to obtain the KKT optimal solutions to the S&C
tradeoff optimization problem.
•Our numerical results reveal that when the line-of-sight
(LOS) component of the communication channel is not
dominated, full-duplex and half-duplex operations are
superior in the communication-prior regime and sensing-
prior regime, respectively. When the communication
channels become LOS-dominated, half-duplex always
outperforms full-duplex due to the strong interference
caused by sensing. It is also shown that the proposed
wideband system requires an additional dedicated sensing
signal for fulfilling the sensing performance, but reusing
the communication signal is sufficient in the narrowband
system.
C. Organization and Notations
The rest of this paper is organized as follows. Section II
presents the half-duplex and full-duplex transmission schemes
for the narrowband bidirectional ISAC system and the S&C
tradeoff optimization problem. Then, an SCA-based algorithm