2
While the spin-orbit torques (SOT) are essential ingredients for the memory application there
have been strong disagreements in the predicted and experimentally measured torques [1] in some
systems including the sign reversal [20–23], suggesting an important piece of physics is still missing.
By the SHE mechanism longitudinal electric current (JC) flowing along the x-direction in the heavy
metals (HM) generates the flow of spins perpendicular to it (along the z-axis, sample growth direction)
while the spins are polarized along y (Fig. 1(a)). Similarly, in certain nonmagnets it has been predicted
to have the flow of transverse orbital momenta (along the z-axis) from the JC (along the x-axis) with the
orbital quantization axis being along y [5] (Fig. 1(a), the orbital moment is normal to the drawn circles).
This is referred to as orbital-Hall current (JOH). Its advantage is that large values of JOH can be found in
abundant material uncorrelated to the SOC that could be used for practical application.
The actions of JSH and JOH are distinctly different on the FM. JSH can directly interact with the
static magnetization of the adjacent FM and thereby produces the damping-like torque (DLT) nearly
independent of the FM in the commonly studied HM/FM bilayers due to the comparable magnitude of
the spin-transparency [1]. On the other hand, JOH does not directly interact with the FM since the orbital
momentum is quenched in the equilibrium state. However, it is recently predicted that the injected JOH
can be converted into the spin-current (JOH
→
S) inside some of the FM using the SOC of the FM as
schematically shown in Fig. 1(b) and hence JOH
→
S would produce a torque on the FM, referred to as
orbital-Hall torque (OHT) [7–9]. Ni is predicted to be very efficient for OHT while Fe is quite inefficient,
suggesting a strong ferromagnet dependence as predicted in the recent theoretical [7–9] and reported in
the previous experimental work [23] and also corroborated in this work by comparing NM/Ni and
NM/Fe60Co20B20 bilayers.
Another key difference between JOH and JSH is the length scale of the angular momenta (spin
or/and orbital) transport inside the FM [9]. For example, the transverse component of the spins is
absorbed within the first few monolayers of the FM [1,24,25] whereas the JOH is predicted to be
transmitted over a long range inside the FM before it is fully converted into the spin-current (JOH
→
S) and
hence expected to result in a long-range torque effect [9]. By systematically varying the thickness of Ni
in NM/Ni bilayer we quantify the long-range torques which is an important outcome of this work and
has not been reported in previously studied systems [15,18,23,26–28]. In presence of both JOH and JSH
we can phenomenologically write the expression for the net damping-like torque () as follows:
(1)
where represents the conventional DLT as observed in the standard HM/FM bilayers in the absence
of JOH. represents the DLT due to the JOH
→
S which is strongly FM dependent [7–9]. The term
suggests the long-range action of the torques and uniquely distinguishes OHT
from the regular SHT as evident in our experiment. is the thickness of the FM while sets the
length scale of the long-range torques. We find that of Ni is approximately 2.5 nm suggesting that
it takes 8-10 nm Ni-thickness to get the full strength of the OHT, nearly an order of magnitude larger
than the length scale of the conventional SHT [24,25].
While the long-range torque is the primary focus of this work, we have also explored the JOH
→
S
using the SOC of a HM (Pt in this case) rather than relying on the SOC of the FM by judiciously
designing the stack: NM/Pt(t)/FM/Pt(t)/cap (Fig. 1(c)). Our proposed device design eliminates the
contribution from the regular SHE due to the symmetric placement of Pt on both sides of the FM which