From the back of the room, a young man in his early thirties stood. "Actually," the man said, "an
observation."
The speaker was dark and thin, dressed in khaki shirt and shorts, precise in his movements and manner.
Malcolm recognized him as a paleontologist from Berkeley named Levine, who was spending the Summer
at the Institute. Malcolm had never spoken to him, but he knew his reputation: Levine was generally agreed
to be the best paleobiologist of his generation, perhaps the best in the world. But most people at the
Institute disliked him, finding him pompous and arrogant.
"I agree," Levine continued, "that the fossil record is not helpful in addressing extinction. Particularly if
your thesis is that behavior is the cause of extinction - because bones don't tell us much about behavior.
But I disagree that your behavioral thesis is untestable. In point of fact, it implies an outcome. Although
perhaps you haven't yet thought of it."
The room was silent. At the podium, Malcolm frowned. The eminent mathematician was not accustomed
to being told he had not thought through his ideas. "What's your point," he said.
Levine appeared indifferent to the tension in the room. "Just this," he said. "During the Cretaceous,
Dinosauria were widely distributed across the planet, We have found their remains on every continent, and
in every climatic zone - even in the Antarctic. Now. If their extinction was really the result of their
behavior, and not the consequence of a Catastrophe, or a disease, or a change in plant life, or any of the
other broad-scale explanations that have been proposed, then it seems to me highly unlikely that they all
changed their behavior at the same time, everywhere. And that in turn means that there may well be some
remnants of these animals still alive on the earth. Why couldn't you look for them?"
"You could," Malcolm said coldly, "if that amused you. And if you had no more compelling use for your
time."
"No, no," Levine said earnestly. "I'm quite serious. What if the dinosaurs did not become extinct? What
if they still exist? Somewhere in an isolated spot on the planet."
"You're talking about a Lost World," Malcolm said, and heads in the room nodded knowingly. Scientists
at the Institute had developed a shorthand for referring to common evolutionary scenarios. They spoke of
the Field of Bullets, the Gambler's Ruin, the Game of Life, the Lost World, the Red Queen, and Black
Noise. These were well-defined ways of thinking about evolution. But they were all -
"No," Levine said stubbornly. "I am speaking literally."
"Then you're badly deluded," Malcolm said, with a dismissive wave of his hand. He turned away from
the audience, and walked slowly to the blackboard. "Now, if we consider the implications of the edge of
chaos, we may begin by asking ourselves, what is the minimal unit of life? Most contemporary definitions
of life would include the presence of DNA, but there are two examples which suggest to us that this
definition is too narrow. If you consider viruses and so-called prions, it is clear that life may in fact exist
without DNA...."
At the back of the room, Levine stared for a moment. Then, reluctantiv he sat down, and began to
make notes.
The Lost World Hypothesis
The lecture ended, Malcolm hobbled across the open courtyard of the Institute, shortly after noon. Walking
beside him was Sarah Harding, a young field biologist visiting from Africa. Malcolm had known her for
several years, since he had been asked to serve as an Outside reader for her doctoral thesis at Berkeley.
Crossing the courtyard in the hot summer sun, they made an unlikely pair: Malcolm dressed in black,
stooped and ascetic, leaning on his cane; Harding compact and muscular, looking young and energetic in
shorts and a tee shirt, her short black hair pushed up on her forehead with sunglasses. Her field of study
was African predators, lions and hyenias. She was scheduled to return to Nairobi the next day.
The two had been close since Malcolm's surgery. Harding had been on a sabbatical year in Austin, and
had helped nurse Malcolm back to health, after his many operations. For a while it seemed as if a romance
had blossomed, and that Malcolm, a confirmed bachelor, would settle down. But then Harding had gone
back to Africa, and Malcolm had gone to Santa Fe. Whatever their former relationship had been, they were
now just friends.
They discussed the questions that had come at the end of his lecture. From Malcolm's point of view,
there had been only the predictable objections: that mass extinctions were important; that human beings
owed their existence to the Cretaceous extinction, which had wiped out the dinosaurs and allowed the