
may yet be, who have been exterminated by the Builders or the Berserkers or any other cause, those
known to us and those who lie in the distant reaches of the Galaxy-beyond-measurement, still unknown
to Carmpan and to brave Solarian alike. The loss of these races means that much (creative work, of
some form) will have to be accomplished (by some unspecified agents) before the Galaxy can be judged
complete and worthy."
That passage was so relatively easy for me to understand, that I believe someone among the Carmpan
must have expended an extraordinary amount of time and effort on it in advance, and that it was then held
ready until the proper moment for its utterance should arrive. Is it possible that the Third Historian himself
is among those we meet and speak with every day? I seriously think it is possible, and at the same time I
doubt that we shall ever know. He could inhabit any of those slow, squarish Carmpan bodies, so
incongruously machinelike in appearance for beings whose own constructed machinery is so subtle, who
try to avoid the grossly material in any form . . . actually, as I think I mentioned in passing above, we
seldom get a really good look at any of the Carmpan here, though we are often physically close to each
other and frequently converse. The rooms in which we most often meet are all niches and alcoves and
low partitions, with enough screens of live greenery to make us feel that we are in a garden instead of
riding a deep-space artifact at a high fraction of the speed of light. The interior lighting is perfect, as I
think I have mentioned, for Solarian eyes, and we can view the Carmpan and even touch them on
arrangement, to satisfy our curiosity. But at the same time privacy is rarely more than an arm's length
away for anyone, and they frequently resort to it, retreating round a corner or behind a hanging vine. We
of course do not intrude upon these temporary retreats. Personally I find myself also retreating sometimes
in the midst of a conversation, gazing out through fresh green leaves of some kind—I am no botanist—or
a fountain's spray, enjoying the whole arrangement more than I would have suspected.
I am rambling. Back to the History Document. What it presents of the Carmpan view of the physical
universe contains no surprise. The Universe just above the galactic level (yet higher levels are implied but
not described) is seen as organized in terms of clusters or groups of galaxies. None of us in the
expedition are astronomers or cosmologists enough to know if the details of this organization as the
Carmpan describe it differ substantially from those mapped out by our own scientists. Actually the Third
Historian uses this physical description only as a background for a question in which he is genuinely
interested: Are there Berserkers, of independent origin, in galaxies other than our own? And, if so, will
the living races of those other megasystems be able to raise up some analog of Solarian humanity to
successfully fight off the unliving foe? This passage, with its understated implication that we are universally
rare stuff indeed, makes me feel, I confess, vaguely uncomfortable.
It was shortly after reading this disturbing passage for the first time that I approached our hosts to
question them on a more personal level: The Third Historian, in some of his early direct communications
to our people, has stated that he "sets down" the "secret thoughts" of Solarian men and women who were
at all times parsecs away from him, as well as being in some instances removed by hundreds of years of
time even when correction is made for all possible relativistic effects. When my hearers affirmed this, I
asked whether any of the Carmpan now present were capable of reading our secret thoughts, and if so,
were they? The answer was quick and emphatic denial, the most definite response I think I have ever had
to any question here. "You and we are too close together," they informed me, "for anything like that."
In HD the Third Historian is also greatly intrigued by another question, related to the one discussed a
paragraph above: May there ever have been, in the remote past of our own Galaxy (the context makes it
plain he is talking about a billion years or more), other Berserkers,independent of those now existing?
He adduces a statement which must be meant as evidence to support this idea, though I cannot
understand it (again, see enclosed recording.) I am haunted by this suggestion, and it makes me wonder if
some of the Elder Races still extant may possibly be of comparable age. It is to me an awesome thought
that some races may have survived a Berserker peril more than once.