Faces
The plant labors all the year, green and growing and undistinguished. At last, in its season,
it blooms, and all the folk remark on the beauty of the flower. Yet that bloom is only the
product of the plant. It is wrong to see the flower as the only important thing, for it is the
plant that makes it—yet it is the aspect of the plant designed to receive attention, and
should be judged as such.
Similarly the writer labors to produce his narrative, and if it is wrong to treat that narrative
as if it had no genesis, still it is the aspect the writer chooses to be represented by. Judge
the writer by his narrative rather than his picture—but do not scorn the picture any more
than the green foliage of the plant, for these may be alternative avenues to comprehension
of the whole.
Alien Plot
I need to make a distinction: The title of this story refers to a plot of ground, while the title
of this collection refers to a dastardly conspiracy. It is the conspiracy by editors to frustrate
writers, and a number of the entries in this volume will harp on that theme. This present
novelette is the major piece of the volume, and the major example.
It started in Mayhem 1990, when I received a solicitation from an editor to contribute a story
to a volume titled After the King: Stories in Honor of J.R.R. Tolkien, to be published in mid-
1992, the 100th anniversary of Professor Tolkien's birth. The guidelines were simple:
stories that were true to the spirit of Tolkien's great accomplishments, or stories that his
work made possible. "Please note," the letter said, "that you cannot use Professor
Tolkien's characters and settings..."
Well, that seemed simple enough. Tolkien made possible the entire modern fantasy genre;
virtually all current fantasy fits under that broad umbrella. As for the spirit of his
accomplishments, let me make this plain: I was a Tolkien fan from the 1940's when I read
The Hobbit, which I considered to be the greatest fantasy adventure ever. I see few
influences by others on my manner of writing, but surely Tolkien had a significant effect. I
didn't like THE LORD OF THE RINGS as well, finding it too long and diffuse, but it was still
great fantasy. It would be hard for me to avoid the spirit of Tolkien in my own fantasy.
But I was jammed for time, because I was answering an average of 150 letters a month that
year and had contracts for half a dozen novels. I couldn't just dash off a token entry; to do
justice to the spirit of Tolkien I would have to make a significant effort. That was apt to put
me behind schedule on my existing projects. So I wrote back, demurring because of the
press of business. But the editor insisted, saying that he really had to have me in that
volume. So, reluctantly, I agreed. I finished the novel I was then in, the 108,000-word
MerCycle, and delayed the next, the 141,000-word Fractal Mode, so as to make space for
the 16,000-word "Alien Plot."
I was not allowed to use any Tolkien setting or character, but was supposed to be true to
the spirit of his fantasy. I pondered, and decided to go whole hog: I made a setting and
characters that were nothing at all like his, but a spirit that was exactly his: that of an
ordinary man getting gradually into something quite alien to the contemporary world, and
finding fulfillment there. The original hobbit really wasn't looking for adventure; he was a
quiet homebody. But before he was through, he had had the greatest adventure of them all.
So I started with an ordinary, undistinguished contemporary man, who longed for the
realms of fantasy, but never expected to experience them. Then, by an unexpected and
strange route, he found himself in just such a realm, and managed to acquit himself
honorably by its odd rules. Just as the original hobbit did. The person was