
Spin canting and lattice symmetry in La2CuO4
Xiao Hu,1A. Sapkota,2, 1 V. O. Garlea,3G. D. Gu,1I. A. Zaliznyak,1and J. M. Tranquada1, ∗
1Condensed Matter Physics and Materials Science Division,
Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, New York 11973-5000, USA
2Ames Laboratory, Iowa State University, Ames, IA 50011, USA.
3Neutron Scattering Division, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37831, USA
(Dated: March 17, 2023)
While the dominant magnetic interaction in La2CuO4is superexchange between nearest-neighbor
Cu moments, the pinning of the spin direction depends on weak anisotropic effects associated with
spin-orbit coupling. The symmetry of the octahedral tilt pattern allows an out-of-plane canting of
the Cu spins, which is compensated by an opposite canting in nearest-neighbor layers. A strong
magnetic field applied perpendicular to the planes can alter the spin canting pattern to induce a weak
ferromagnetic phase. In light of recent evidence that the lattice symmetry is lower than originally
assumed, we take a new look at the nature of the field-induced spin-rotation transition. Comparing
low-temperature neutron diffraction intensities for several magnetic Bragg peaks measured in fields
of 0 and 14 T, we find that a better fit is provided by a model in which spins rotate within both
neighboring planes but by different amounts, resulting in a noncollinear configuration. This model
allows a more consistent relationship between lattice symmetry and spin orientation at all Cu sites.
I. INTRODUCTION
Interest in La2CuO4, the parent compound of the orig-
inal high-temperature superconductor family [1, 2], was
renewed recently with the discovery by Taillefer and
coworkers that, at low temperature, it exhibits an un-
usually large thermal Hall conductivity [3]. The origi-
nal measurements were performed in a c-axis magnetic
field of 15 T, which puts the system into the weak ferro-
magnetic phase, associated with a field-induced in-phase
alignment of the small out-of-plane canting of the Cu
spins [4, 5]. Further studies have provided evidence that
the thermal Hall conductivity is due to phonons [6] and
that a sizable response can also be found in nonmag-
netic compounds such as SrTiO3[7]. While a number of
possible explanations based on intrinsic effects have been
proposed [8–10], extrinsic effects involving skew scatter-
ing off of defects might be the dominant effect [11, 12].
Nevertheless, experimentalists have discussed the effect
in terms of chiral phonons [6, 13].
Following on work by Reehuis et al. [5], we re-
cently demonstrated [14] that the structural symmetry
of La2CuO4is lower than originally determined [15, 16].
In particular, the ordered rotation of the CuO6octahe-
dra includes a small component rotated around the Cu-O
bond axis, with associated anomalous soft phonons. A
complete softening of such phonons occurs in the related
compound La1.8Eu0.2CuO4below 133 K [17]. Similari-
ties between the magnetization of that low-temperature
phase and the field-induced weak-ferromagnetic phase of
La2CuO4led us to wonder whether the soft phonons
might couple to the canted spins in an interesting way
(despite the fact that measurements on other cuprates
indicate that canted moments are not essential for obser-
vation of a large thermal Hall conductivity [13]).
∗jtran@bnl.gov
We have used neutron scattering to study the impact
of a 14-T magnetic field applied along the c-axis of a
crystal of La2CuO4. We find that the crystal structure
is quite stable to the field, and no significant change to
phonons was detected. The measurements did, however,
provide an opportunity to reconsider the proposed model
for the weak ferromagnetic phase. We propose a new
model involving a noncollinear arrangement of spins in
neighboring planes and show that it gives a better fit to
our measured magnetic peak intensities.
To provide context, we note that, as La2CuO4is a
charge-transfer correlated insulator [18, 19], it exhibits
strong antiferromagnetic correlations within the CuO2
planes from high temperatures [20–22] driven by a large
nearest-neighbor superexchange energy [23, 24]. Antifer-
romagnetic order [25, 26] develops below a N´eel temper-
ature of TN∼325 K [27], which is sensitive to oxygen
stoichiometry [28]. While the ordered Cu moments lie
largely within the CuO2planes [see Fig. 1(a)] [25], there
is a small canting perpendicular to the planes that is ap-
parent as a rise in the magnetization (measured with a
field perpendicular to the planes) on cooling toward TN,
where the magnetic layers are decoupled; below TN, the
canting in neighboring layers cancels out, resulting in a
decrease in the magnetization [29, 30]. The approximate
magnetic structure and its relation to the octahedral tilt
pattern are illustrated in Fig. 1(a).
The spin canting has been explained [29] as a con-
sequence of exchange terms resulting from the effects of
spin-orbit coupling as originally identified by Dzyaloshin-
sky [31] and Moriya [32] (DM). The evaluation of the DM
interaction for cuprates with particular lattice symme-
tries is not trivial, and it received considerable attention
in the decade following the discovery of cuprate super-
conductivity [33–40].
Empirically, the moment direction and canting in zero
field are found to be orthogonal to the octahedral rota-
tion axis [17, 41]; this comes from studies of Nd- and Eu-
arXiv:2210.01156v3 [cond-mat.str-el] 16 Mar 2023