
Mirror symmetry breaking of superradiance in a dipolar BEC
Bojeong Seo,1, ∗Mingchen Huang,1, ∗Ziting Chen,1Mithilesh
K. Parit,1Yifei He,1Peng Chen,1and Gyu-Boong Jo1, 2, †
1Department of Physics, The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, Clear Water Bay, Kowloon, Hong Kong, China
2IAS Center for Quantum Technologies, The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, Kowloon, Hong Kong, China
Dicke superradiance occurs when two or more emitters cooperatively interact via the electro-
magnetic field. This collective light scattering process has been extensively studied across various
platforms, from atoms to quantum dots and organic molecules. Despite extensive research, the
precise role of direct interactions between emitters in superradiance remains elusive, particularly in
many-body systems where the complexity of interactions poses significant challenges. In this study,
we investigate the effect of dipole-dipole interaction between 18,000 atoms in dipolar Bose-Einstein
condensates (BECs) on the superradiance process. In dipolar BECs, we simplify the complex effect
of anisotropic magnetic dipole-dipole interaction with Bogoliubov transformation. We observe that
anisotropic Bogoliubov excitation breaks the mirror symmetry in decay modes of superradiance.
Collective light scattering [1], a cooperative emission
process inducing directional scattered atoms, has been
observed in various atomic systems ranging from ther-
mal atoms [2, 3], degenerate Bose gases [4–12], free
fermions [13] to atoms coupled to the cavity mode [14–
16]. Among them, a Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) has
served as a promising platform for exploring a superra-
diant light scattering process owing to its unique coher-
ence property with [4–12, 17] and without external light
fields [18–21]. When the external light shines on atoms
in the condensate, collective scattering of light creates a
quasiparticle in the form of recoiling atoms that interfere
with condensate atoms at rest, leading to the generation
of matter-wave grating that is further enhanced by sub-
sequent light scattering [22]. So far, however, prior stud-
ies have primarily focused on a non-interacting regime,
leaving the effect of interactions largely unexplored [23–
26]. This makes it challenging to explore exotic states
of matter using light scattering even though fundamen-
tal excitations in exotic states are expected to manifest
themselves in the light-matter interaction process [27].
In this work, we investigate a superradiance light scat-
tering process from a dipolar BEC in an elongated trap,
in which the mirror symmetry in superradiance is bro-
ken due to the dipolar intearction. Here, magnetic dipo-
lar interactions result in anisotropic dispersion of dipo-
lar superfluid [24, 25], which allows us to control the
asymmetry of superradiant peaks by changing the direc-
tion of the external magnetic field. Such dipolar effects
in quantum gases [28] have recently opened up a new
regime where anisotropic dipole-dipole interactions play
a crucial role in realizing new phases of matter, such as
quantum droplets and supersolids [28]. Our work demon-
strates how fundamental excitations begin to contribute
and manifest themselves in light-matter interaction pro-
cesses.
∗These authors contributed equally.
†gbjo@ust.hk
Experiment We initiate experiments with a quasi-
one-dimensional dipolar BEC of approximately 1.8×104
erbium (168Er) atoms in the |MJ=−6⟩state [29–31]. By
aligning the dipole orientation along a specified direction
(parallel to an external magnetic field), we excited the
ground state BEC at |q= 0⟩to an excited state |e⟩using
a largely detuned pump beam. This excited state then
decays back to the ground state, acquiring non-zero mo-
mentum in the process due to momentum conservation.
In a typical condensate without dipolar interactions, this
scattering process is amplified along the long axis of the
condensate [4–6]. It leads to decay in two opposite direc-
tions symmetrically and emits photons with momentum
ℏk583, where k583 represents the wavevector of the pump
beam. As a result of this symmetric light-scattering pro-
cess, the quasi-particles are created with the momentum
of √2ℏk583 along the 45◦relative to the long-axis of the
condensate ((see Fig. 1(a)). We can simplify our model
by eliminating the intermediate excited state and con-
sidering a two-level system comprising the initial state
at |q= 0⟩and a final state at |q=√2ℏk583⟩, owing to
the relatively large detuning (∆) of the pump beam com-
pared to the Rabi frequency (Ω) of the driving field and
the spontaneous emission rate from |e⟩to |q=k583⟩.
A distinct feature of a dipolar BEC, as opposed
to one with only isotropic contact interactions, is its
anisotropic dispersion relation due to dipole-dipole inter-
actions. The elementary anisotropic dipolar Bogoliubov
excitation spectrum, ℏω(q), for a uniform density nis
expressed as
ℏω(q) = pE(q)(E(q)+2gn(1 + ϵdd(3 cos2ϕ−1))) (1)
where E(q) = ℏ2q2
2mand ϕis the angle between the ex-
ternal magnetic field and the atomic excitation direc-
tion. Here, g= 4πℏ2as/m with atomic mass mand
ϵdd =add/asfor the characterisitc dipolar length of
add=66.3a0. This leads to a broken symmetry in the two
end-fire modes, as evident from the asymmetry in their
decay rates, Γ′
L̸= Γ′
R(see Fig. 1(b)). In consequence,
one decay channel becomes dominant in the scattering
arXiv:2210.01586v4 [cond-mat.quant-gas] 13 Sep 2024