
Bremsstrahlung photon from a hadronizing quark-gluon plasma
Taesoo Song1, ∗
1GSI Helmholtzzentrum f¨ur Schwerionenforschung GmbH, Planckstrasse 1, 64291 Darmstadt, Germany
Assuming that quark and antiquark numbers are separately conserved during hadronization, we
calculate Bremsstrahlung photon from a hadronizing quark-gluon plasma. The quark and antiquark
numbers are obtained from the hadron numbers in the statistical model and the transition amplitudes
for the hadronization from the constraint that all quarks and antiquarks must be consumed in the
hadronization. Then Bremsstrahlung photon from the hadronization is obtained in the soft photon
approximation, and we find that its contribution to the direct photon increases in low-energy heavy-
ion collisions and in peripheral collisions where the lifetime of a quark-gluon plasma (QGP) is
relatively short.
PACS numbers:
I. INTRODUCTION
Ultra-relativistic heavy-ion collisions produce an ex-
tremely hot and dense nuclear matter which is possibly
related to the state of the early universe. Electromag-
netic particles such as dilepton (virtual photon) and real
photon are promising probe particles searching for the
properties of the extreme matter. Since they have no
strong charge, they do not interact with the produced
matter but get through it without being interrupted.
Therefore, they deliver the information of the matter at
their production sites and times [1, 2].
The produced photons in heavy-ion collisions are clas-
sified into the decay photon and the direct photon. The
former is produed through the electromagnetic decay of
hadrons, while the latter from the interactions of particles
both in partonic and hadronic phases. The direct photon
is more interesting, because it discloses the properties of
the matter.
Several years ago it has been measured at the RHIC
and LHC that the elliptic flows of direct photon in heavy-
ion collisions are comparable to those of pion and decay
photon, which is called ’direct photon puzzle,’ because
the direct photon is continually produced from the initial
stage where elliptic flows are not developed yet [2–8].
One possible way to explain the large elliptic flows is
that direct photons are mainly produced in the late stage
such as hadronic phase [9] rather than in partonic phase,
and the out-of-equilibrium photon production might help
it [10].
Production channels of direct photon in heavy-ion col-
lisions are catogorized according to production stage.
The first one is the prouction before thermalization of
the matter, which includes the primordial production and
the pre-equilibrium one. The former is the production
through the scattering of partons in the colliding nucle-
ons, which is calculable in pQCD. Since the same photon
is produced in p+p collisions, it can be scaled by the
∗Electronic address: t.song@gsi.de
number of binary collisions in heavy-ion collisions. The
latter is presently unclear and depends on model for the
pre-equilibrium matter [11–14].
The second and third ones are, respectively, partonic
and hadronic productions after the thermalization. The
dominant channels in QGP are q(¯q) + g→q+γand
q+ ¯q→g+γwhile in the hadron gas phase π+π→ρ+γ
and π+ρ→π+γwith πand ρbeing changable to K
and K∗, respectively.
Other source of direct photon in both partonic and
hadronic matter is Bremsstrahlung photon which is in-
duced by the interactions of charged particles. In QGP,
for example, q(¯q) + q(¯q) and q(¯q) + gscatterings can pro-
duce Bremsstrahlung photon, because (anti)quark has
nonzero electric charge.
Hadronization is a kind of interaction which con-
fines free (anti)quarks into a bound state of hadron.
However, photon production from hadronization has
barely been studied [15–19]. According to the lat-
tice calculations the phase transition is crossover at
small baryon chemical potential [20], and the hadroniza-
tion will be a smooth continous transition from the
thermal distribution of free (anti)quarks to the ther-
mal distribution of free hadrons [21]. Though it is
not an instant interaction, the momentum changes of
(anti)quarks through the hadronization will bring about
the emission of Bremsstrahlung photon. Since low-
energy Bremsstrahlung photon is not affected by micro-
scopic process but by macroscopic process, the incom-
ing and outgoing momenta of (anti)quarks are the only
necessary input to study the production of low-energy
Bremsstrahlung photon [22, 23].
Hadronization happens in an extremely nonperturba-
tive region of QCD and many things of it are not well
known. In this study we rely on the statistical model
to obtain quark and antiquark number densities at Tc,
assuming that quark and antiquark numbers are seper-
ately conserved during the hadronization and they play
the role of constituent quarks and constituent antiquarks
of hadrons. The transition amplitudes for hadronization
are determined from the contraint that all quarks and
antiquarks are consumed during the hadronization.
We first calculate the photon production from me-
arXiv:2210.04007v2 [nucl-th] 16 Feb 2023