Analyzing Distribution Transformer Degradation
with Increased Power Electronic Loads
Bhaskar Mitra, Ankit Singhal, Soumya Kundu and James P. Ogle
Electricity Infrastructure and Buildings Division
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory
Richland, WA 99354, USA
Email: {bhaskar.mitra, ankit.singhal, soumya.kundu, james.ogle}@pnnl.gov
Abstract—The influx of non-linear power electronic loads into
the distribution network has the potential to disrupt the existing
distribution transformer operations. They were not designed
to mediate the excessive heating losses generated from the
harmonics. To have a good understanding of current standing
challenges, a knowledge of the generation and load mix as well
as the current harmonic estimations are essential for designing
transformers and evaluating their performance. In this paper,
we investigate a mixture of essential power electronic loads for
a household designed in PSCAD/EMTdc and their potential
impacts on transformer eddy current losses and derating using
harmonic analysis. The various scenarios have been studied with
increasing PV penetrations. The peak load conditions are chosen
for each scenario to perform a transformer derating analysis.
Our findings reveal that in the presence of high power electronic
loads (especially third harmonics), along with increasing PV
generation may worsen transformer degradation. However, with
a low amount of power electronic loads, additional PV generation
helps to reduce the harmonic content in the current and improve
transformer performance.
Index Terms—eddy current, harmonics, power transformer,
PV, THD
I. INTRODUCTION
Power electronic loads have found a wider application in
power system networks especially after their advancement in
the late 1900s. Many loads require essential power electronic
converters for stage conversion. Some common examples of
power electronic loads include uninterrupted power supply
(UPS) devices, personal computers, laptops, electric vehicle
chargers, etc. These non-linear loads contribute to non-linear
sinusoidal currents. The non-sinusoidal currents, when passing
through network impedance, create a non-sinusoidal voltage
drop [1]. The non-sinusoidal voltage and current components
are integer multiples of the fundamental component called
“harmonics”. The deterioration of the supply voltage creates
stress on the electrical equipment and can potentially damage
it, resulting in increased operating costs and downtime [2].
Increased voltage and current harmonics are found to have
a direct relationship to premature aging and degradation of
transformers. Initial transformer designs were made consid-
ering conventional load models, i.e., Constant Impedance
(Z), Constant Current (I), and Constant Power (P) or “ZIP”
This work was supported by the Sensors and Data Analytics Program of
the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Electricity, under Contract No. DE-
AC05-76RL01830.
models, that would operate at fundamental 60Hz or 50Hz
frequency [3, 4]. Under the increased penetration of non-linear
loads, the design of power transformers needs to be reassessed
to ensure proper and safe operation. Increased non-linear loads
increase the transformer losses due to overheating of the core,
creating a larger derating factor [5, 6].
The problem of harmonics is more evident with customers
on the low-voltage end. The common household equipment
includes but not limited to desktops, laptops, LED lamps,
variable speed drives, solar panels, etc. To compound the
challenges, as more and more electric vehicles come to the
market, they rely majorly on at-home charging that produces
a large fraction of non-linear voltage and current. Certain
power electronic devices like VFD’s contribute more 3rd
harmonics, if they are not properly compensated it would lead
to additional losses and loss-of-life for the transformer. The
addition of harmonics has an effect on transformer protection
as well. Addition of the 5th harmonic needs to be compensated
below a certain threshold before the protection relays can be
engaged. The distorted harmonic waveforms results in loss of
essential information for protection, this might result in the
protection devices operating slower [7].
Currently, there is a gap in high-fidelity load models that can
capture the typical characteristics of non-linear models, i.e.,
the cross-coupling effect of voltages and current. A harmonic-
rich current/voltage dataset is essential to understand the effect
on transformer losses, heating, etc. “ZIP” based harmonic load
models suffer from a lack of enhanced harmonic spectrum that
can be observed through the operation of various non-linear
devices [8]. Real-world field data is not publicly available to
perform such analysis. Methods relying on laboratory setups
to develop such datasets fail to capture the effect on other
nonlinear load currents.
Therefore, in this paper, (i) we perform an analysis of
residential transformer heating and losses encountered due to
the presence of non-linear power electronic residential loads
using PSCAD/EMTdc. Detailed power electronic models are
developed to create harmonic rich datasets to entail their effect
on transformer operation; (ii) Different loading scenarios on
the transformer are assessed with increasing PV penetration
to understand its effect on THD(%), eddy current losses, and
the subsequent impact on transformer derating.
The rest of the paper has been organized in the following
arXiv:2210.14824v1 [eess.SY] 26 Oct 2022