
Neutron Lifetime Anomaly and Big Bang Nucleosynthesis
Tammi Chowdhury1, ∗and Seyda Ipek1, †
1Carleton University 1125 Colonel By Drive, Ottawa, Ontario K1S 5B6, Canada
We calculate the Big Bang Nucleosynthesis abundances for helium-4 and deuterium for a range
of neutron lifetimes, τn= 840 −1050 s, using the state-of-the-art Python package PRyMordial.
We show the results for two different nuclear reaction rates, calculated by NACRE II [1] and the
PRIMAT [2] collaborations.
I. INTRODUCTION
The primordial abundances of light elements are the
earliest measurements of the history of our universe.
During the Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) era, cor-
responding to temperatures T∼O(MeV), light elements
such as helium, deuterium, tritium, lithium and beryl-
lium were produced as a result of nuclear reactions pre-
dicted in the Standard Model (SM). The final abundances
depend on parameters such as the number of relativistic
species (Neff ), baryon-to-photon ratio η, neutron-proton
mass difference and the neutron lifetime τn. These pa-
rameters can all be calculated within the SM or mea-
sured in SM processes, except η, whose value can be
determined from BBN and the cosmic microwave back-
ground (CMB) individually. Given the SM predictions
for BBN abundances, the primordial abundance measure-
ments can then be used to constrain new physics beyond
the SM.
There has been a consistent discrepancy between two
different methods of measuring the neutron lifetime in
the last decades, suggesting possible new physics. As
will be described in the next section, “bottle” experi-
ments give τn= 878.4±0.5 s [3] while “beam” exper-
iments find a higher value of τn= 888.45 ±1.65 s [4].
Neutron lifetime is an important ingredient in calculat-
ing the SM predictions of BBN abundances. Thus, BBN
measurements can be compared to theoretical expecta-
tions to extract the neutron lifetime. This possibility has
been studied in the literature [5,6]. We revisit this idea
in light of newest neutron lifetime measurements, BBN
observations as well as updates on nuclear rates that go
into BBN calculations. We use a recent Python package
PRyMordial [7]. (See [8] for details about the pro-
gram.) Our results are shown in Figure 1.
II. NEUTRON LIFETIME ANOMALY
In the SM the neutron decays to a proton, an elec-
tron and antineutrino via electroweak interactions, n→
∗Tammi.Chowdhury@carleton.ca
†Seyda.Ipek@carleton.ca
p e−¯ν1. The SM decay rate is [9]
τn=4908.7(1.9) s
|Vud|2(1 + 3g2
A),(1)
where Vud = 0.97370 ±0.00014 is an element of the
Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) quark mixing ma-
trix and gA≡GA/GV≃1.27 is the ratio of axial and
vector couplings.
Neutron lifetime is measured using two experimen-
tal methods. In the bottle method ultracold neutrons
(UCNs) are trapped in a container. After a time com-
parable to the expected neutron lifetime, the remaining
neutrons are counted. In the beam method a slow neu-
tron beam decays in an experimental volume. The decay
products, protons and electrons, and the remaining neu-
trons are captured. Given the neutron flux, the beam
method measures the amount of neutrons that decayed
into protons in a decay volume. This then can be trans-
lated to a neutron lifetime, assuming neutrons only decay
in this way. (See [10] for a historical review of neutron
lifetime measurements.) These two methods give
τbottle
n= 878.4±0.5 s τbeam
n= 888.45 ±1.65 s ,(2)
with more than 4σdiscrepancy between the two mea-
surement methods. This discrepancy could be due to
unaccounted-for systematic errors in one or both meth-
ods or it could be due to new physics beyond the SM [11–
15]. For example, if neutron decays to dark matter, beam
experiments, which count the decay products, would in-
terpret that as a longer (SM) neutron lifetime while bot-
tle experiments, which are blind to different decay chan-
nels, will still measure the total neutron lifetime.
Very recently space-based measurements of the neu-
tron lifetime emerged [16,17]. Neutrons are freed from
the surface of planetary objects by galactic cosmic rays.
These neutrons thermalize with the atmosphere with ve-
locities of a few km/s. Spacecrafts that are O(1000 km)
above the surface of the planetary object can be sen-
sitive to the neutron lifetime by measuring the neutron
flux from the object’s surface, given its elemental compo-
sition. NASA’s MESSENGER spacecraft performed such
1A small fraction, about 10−3, of decays produce final states with
a photon. Even more rarely there will be decays in which electron
binds to the proton to form a hydrogen atom.
arXiv:2210.12031v2 [hep-ph] 19 Oct 2023