
Classical Half-Adder using Trapped-ion Quantum Bits:
Towards Energy-efficient Computation
Sagar Silva Pratapsi,1, 2, a) Patrick H. Huber,3, a) Patrick Barthel,3Sougato Bose,4Christof Wunderlich,3, a) and
Yasser Omar1, 5, 6, a)
1)Instituto Superior Técnico, University of Lisbon, Lisbon 1049-001, Portugal.
2)Instituto de Telecomunicações, Lisbon 1049-001, Portugal.
3)Department of Physics, School of Science and Technology, University of Siegen, 57068 Siegen,
Germany
4)Department of Physics and Astronomy, University College London, London WC1E 6BT,
UK
5)Physics of Information and Quantum Technologies group, Center of Physics and Engineering of Advanced Materials (CeFEMA),
Lisbon 1049-001, Portugal
6)PQI – Portuguese Quantum Institute, Lisbon 1600-531, Portugal
(*Electronic mail: contact.yasser@pqi.pt)
(*Electronic mail: Christof.Wunderlich@uni-siegen.de)
(*Electronic mail: p.huber@physik.uni-siegen.de)
(*Electronic mail: spratapsi@tecnico.ulisboa.pt)
(Dated: 5 April 2024)
Reversible computation has been proposed as a future paradigm for energy efficient computation, but so far few imple-
mentations have been realised in practice. Quantum circuits, running on quantum computers, are one construct known
to be reversible. In this work, we provide a proof-of-principle of classical logical gates running on quantum tech-
nologies. In particular, we propose, and realise experimentally, Toffoli and Half-Adder circuits suitable for classical
computation, using radiofrequency-controlled 171Yb+ions in a macroscopic linear Paul-trap as qubits. We analyse the
energy required to operate the logic gates, both theoretically and experimentally, with a focus on the control energy.
We identify bottlenecks and possible improvements in future platforms for energetically-efficient computation, e.g.,
trap chips with integrated antennas and cavity QED. Our experimentally verified energetic model also fills a gap in the
literature of the energetics of quantum information, and outlines the path for its detailed study, as well as its potential
applications to classical computing.
Computational tasks are responsible for a non-negligible
part of the world’s energy consumption. It is estimated that
computationally-intensive data-centres represent 1% of the
global energy budget1. So far, increases in energy efficiency
have been able to offset the growing demand for computation:
peak-usage energy efficiency has doubled every 1.5 years dur-
ing the 1960–2000 period, while since the 2000s this figure
is closer to 2.6 years1,2. However, processor efficiency gains
cannot continue to grow forever. There is a fundamental limi-
tation of the current paradigm of non-reversible computation,
known as Landauer’s principle3, where each irreversible bit
operation dissipates kBTln2 of heat.
Reversible computation may thus become an important
computation paradigm in the future. Reversible systems
may also avoid the heat costs of contemporary CMOS pro-
cessors, such as capacitor charging, switching and current
leakage4,5, which are ultimately responsible for the typical
40% energy cost for cooling in data centres6; they may also
protect against external attacks such as power usage anal-
ysis. It is, then, worthwhile to investigate how energy-
efficient reversible platforms can become. Some propos-
als for reversible computing platforms have been billiard-
ball models7,8, adiabatic circuits9–13, nano-machines14–18, su-
a)Corresponding author.
perconducting devices19–21, quantum-dot cellular automata22,
and others (see23 for a review of reversible computation).
But, so far, experimental realisations of reversible compu-
tation are lacking in practice. Quantum mechanical sys-
tems, which evolve unitarily, are also reversible by nature,
and are thus an attractive candidate for energetically efficient
computation24,25. Although quantum platforms are limited by
coherence time, we can reset the coherence for classical com-
putations by measuring in the computational basis in-between
logical operations. We may also exploit super-selection rules
to protect classical information, as was proposed recently in
a quantum dot platform26. Can we then build energy efficient
circuits for universal reversible computation using quantum
computing platforms?
In this work, we explore an implementation of reversible
computation using quantum technologies, by realising a clas-
sical Half-Adder circuit—an important building block for
arithmetic operations27—using quantum states of trapped
ions. To do so, we implement a Toffoli gate, itself a univer-
sal gate for classical computation. We determine the energy
to operate these gates, both theoretically and experimentally,
with a special focus on the energy required to activate and con-
trol the logical gates, focusing on the power delivered to the
Quantum Processing Unit (QPU), as defined later. We point
out possible improvements towards energy efficient computa-
tion. Some works28 require realistic estimates for the energy
arXiv:2210.10470v2 [quant-ph] 4 Apr 2024