
Lorentz invariance violation induced threshold anomaly versus very-high energy
cosmic photon emission from GRB 221009A
Hao Lia, Bo-Qiang Maa,b,c,∗
aSchool of Physics, Peking University, Beijing 100871, China
bCenter for High Energy Physics, Peking University, Beijing 100871, China
cCollaborative Innovation Center of Quantum Matter, Beijing, China
Abstract
It has been reported that the Large High Altitude Air Shower Observatory (LHAASO) observed very high energy
photons from GRB 221009A, with the highest energy reaching 18 TeV. We find that observation of such high energy
photons is quite nontrivial since extragalactic background light could absorb these photons severely and the flux is too
weak to be observed. Therefore we discuss a potential mechanism for us to observe these photons, and suggest that
Lorentz invariance violation induced threshold anomaly of the process γγ →e−e+provides a candidate to explain this
phenomenon.
Keywords:
Lorentz invariance violation, threshold anomaly, very high energy photons, gamma-ray burst
On 9 October 2022, a special gamma-ray burst (GRB)
was reported first by Fermi and Swift and is numbered
as GRB 221009A [1–7]. This burst, located at around
RA = 288.282 and Dec = 19.495 [4], is a long burst but
with a very small redshift z= 0.1505 [8,9] compared to
most other long bursts. More remarkably, the extraor-
dinary brightness of this burst immediately makes this
burst a very interesting object for studying various as-
pects of physics and astronomy. The highest energy pho-
ton observed by Fermi-LAT reaches 99.3 GeV [4], while
more strikingly, the Large High Altitude Air Shower Ob-
servatory (LHAASO) reported more than 5000 very high
energy photon events with energies above 500 GeV, in-
cluding photons with the energy up to 18 TeV, making
these photons the most energetic GRB photons ever ob-
served [10]. This unexpected observation of 18 TeV pho-
tons immediately brings a new question: can we observe
photons with this energy if we consider only the standard
knowledge of the Universe and particle physics? In the fol-
lowing we study the background light absorption of such
photons in the Universe, show that we may need to invoke
new mechanism to explain this observation. We also argue
that Lorentz invariance violation (LIV) induced threshold
anomaly [11–19] provides a potential solution.
The Fermi Gamma-Ray Burst Monitor was triggered at
13:16:59.99 UT on 9 October 2022, and then located GRB
221009A [1,2]. LHAASO also joined in the observation of
this GRB. Since LHAASO is designed for gamma-ray as-
∗Corresponding author
Email addresses: haolee@pku.edu.cn (Hao Li),
mabq@pku.edu.cn (Bo-Qiang Ma)
tronomy in the energy band between 1011 and 1015 eV [20–
23], it eventually reveals the very high energy property of
this burst. The most intriguing result of LHAASO is that
there are photons of about 18 TeV [10]. These photons
can be used to help us understand the features of GRBs,
and also we can utilize them to study the propagation of
high energy photons in the Universe. According to the
standard model of particle physics, two photons can an-
nihilate with each other and produce an electron-positron
pair: γγ →e−e+. This annihilation process then prohibits
high energy photons from propagating a long distance in
the Universe since they can react with background photons
such as those from cosmic microwave background (CMB)
and extragalactic background light (EBL). Let Eand εb
be the energies of the high energy photon and the back-
ground photon respectively, then according to special rel-
ativity we can easily derive the threshold for this reaction
to happen [18,19]:
E≥Eth =m2
e
εb
,(1)
where meis the mass of electrons. For CMB photons, the
mean energy is εb'6.35×10−4eV, resulting in a threshold
energy ECMB
th '411 TeV [18,19], which indicates that
CMB is almost transparent to the LHAASO photon of
18 TeV. However, for EBL photons the situation could
be more complicated. As a rough estimate, we can take
εb'10−3eV to 1 eV according to the distribution of EBL,
leading to the corresponding thresholds Eth '261 GeV to
261 TeV [19]. As a result, EBL photons do matter to
cause an attenuation of cosmic photon propagation in the
analysis of the LHAASO photons of above 10 TeV [19]. In
Preprint submitted to Astroparticle Physics 148 (2023) 102831 doi:10.1016/j.astropartphys.2023.102831 March 7, 2023
arXiv:2210.06338v6 [astro-ph.HE] 4 Mar 2023