
Thermal disruption of a Luttinger liquid
Danyel Cavazos-Cavazos1, Ruwan Senaratne1, Aashish Kafle1, and Randall G. Hulet1(email:randy@rice.edu)
1Department of Physics and Astronomy, Rice University, Houston, Texas 77005, USA
The Tomonaga-Luttinger liquid (TLL) theory
describes the low-energy excitations of strongly
correlated one-dimensional (1D) fermions. In
the past years, a number of studies have pro-
vided a detailed understanding of this universality
class. More recently, theoretical investigations that
go beyond the standard low-temperature, linear-
response, TLL regime have been developed. While
these provide a basis for understanding the dynam-
ics of the spin-incoherent Luttinger liquid, there
are few experimental investigations in this regime.
Here we report the observation of a thermally-
induced, spin-incoherent Luttinger liquid in a 6Li
atomic Fermi gas confined to 1D. We use Bragg
spectroscopy to measure the suppression of spin-
charge separation and the decay of correlations as
the temperature is increased. Our results probe
the crossover between the coherent and incoher-
ent regimes of the Luttinger liquid, and elucidate
the roles of the charge and the spin degrees of
freedom in this regime.
Studies of strongly interacting atomic gases in 1D,
aided by exactly solvable models1–6, have provided re-
markable insight into the physics of highly-correlated
quantum many-body systems in regimes that are in-
creasingly accessible to experiment7–14. The low-energy
properties of spin-1/2 fermions in 1D are well under-
stood in terms of the TLL theory15–19, which features
low-energy collective spin- and charge-density waves
(SDWs/CDWs). These sound waves propagate with
different velocities, thus resulting in a spin-charge sepa-
ration. At its core, the TLL universality class is charac-
terized by collective excitations that are coherent and
linearly dispersing. Several regimes, however, have
been found to extend beyond this spin-charge separa-
tion paradigm, allowing access to new classes of un-
conventional Luttinger liquids where the coherence of
the excitations is disrupted20–22. Higher-order effects
such as band-curvature and back-scattering, for exam-
ple, produce a nonlinear Luttinger liquid23, for which the
linearity of the dispersion is disrupted. Spin polariza-
tion is expected to control a quantum phase transition,
at which the TLL turns quantum critical and all ther-
modynamic quantities exhibit universal scaling22. Al-
lowing for anisotropic coupling between 1D chains of
fermions could realize the sliding Luttinger liquid (SLL)
phase24. Topological materials such as single- and bi-
layer graphene25 provide access to phases such as chiral
Luttinger liquids26 (χLL), which host excitation modes
with a preferred sense of propagation.
Finite temperature represents another pathway for
disrupting the correlations in a TLL (Fig. 1a). In the
low temperature (T) limit, the thermal energy kBTis
the lowest energy scale and both the charge- and spin-
density waves propagate coherently in accordance with
the standard TLL theory, thus defining the spin-coherent
(SC) regime. As Tis increased, thermal fluctuations
disrupt the coherence in the spin sector first, and the
system enters the spin-incoherent (SI) Luttinger liquid
regime27. In the SI regime, spin-spin correlations are
expected to exhibit a rapid exponential decay while the
density-density correlations retain a slower algebraic de-
cay, leading to correlations that are independent from
the spin sector28. The SI regime has been investigated
theoretically with the Bethe ansatz28, 29 and a bosonized
path integral approach31–33 to describe both fermions34
and bosons35. Recent studies have also identified den-
sity correlations28, 34, 36 that distinguish the SC and the
SI regimes. Experimental evidence for the SI regime,
however, remains scarce. Studies of quasi-1D solid-
state materials using angle-resolved photoemission spec-
troscopy37, 38 have suggested that signatures of the SI
regime arise for small electron densities39. The con-
trol and tunability afforded by ultracold gases, on the
other hand, facilitate systematic study of Luttinger liq-
uid physics10–12, 14.
Here, we explore the crossover between a SC Lut-
tinger liquid and the SI regime in a pseudo-spin-1/2 gas
of 6Li atoms loaded into an array of 1D waveguides. We
use Bragg spectroscopy to show the suppression of spin-
charge separation and the systematic loss of coherence
with increasing T. Surprisingly, signatures of the spin
degree of freedom persist even for T > TF, where TFis
the Fermi temperature.
Spin-charge separation results in a separation of en-
ergy scales for the spin and the charge sectors of the TLL
1
arXiv:2210.06306v2 [cond-mat.quant-gas] 2 Jun 2023