Dynamical Effects from Anomaly: Modified Electrodynamics in Weyl Semimetal
Xuzhe Ying,1, 2 A. A. Burkov,1, 2 and Chong Wang2
1Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON, N2L 3G1, Canada
2Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics, Waterloo, ON, N2L 2Y5, Canada
We discuss the modified quantum electrodynamics from a time-reversal-breaking Weyl semimetal
coupled with a U(1)gauge (electromagnetic) field. A key role is played by the soft dispersion of
the photons in a particular direction, say ˆz, due to the Hall conductivity of the Weyl semimetal.
Due to the soft photon, the fermion velocity in ˆzis logarithmically reduced under renormalization
group flow, together with the fine structure constant. Meanwhile, fermions acquire a finite lifetime
from spontaneous emission of the soft photon, namely the Cherenkov radiation. At low energy E,
the inverse of the fermion lifetime scales as τ−1∼E/PolyLog(E). Therefore, even though fermion
quasiparticles are eventually well-defined at very low energy, over a wide intermediate energy window
the Weyl semimetal behaves like a marginal Fermi liquid. Phenomenologically, our results are more
relevant for emergent Weyl semimetals, where the fermions and photons all emerge from strongly
correlated lattice systems. Possible experimental implications are discussed.
PACS numbers:
I. INTRODUCTION
Weyl fermions, since their original proposal, have been
widely studied due to the chiral nature [1–9]. In the
recent decades, much focus has been put on the con-
densed matter realization, namely the Weyl semimetal
(WSM) [7–10]. In Weyl semimetals, due to the separa-
tion of Weyl fermions in momentum space, various in-
triguing phenomena have been observed, e.g., Fermi arc
[8,9], anomalous Hall effect [7,11], quantized circular pho-
togalvanic effect [12], etc. The dynamical properties of
WSM also attract much attention [13–16]. While a mag-
netic Weyl semimetal is typically subject to weak inter-
action of particular form (short-ranged or Coulomb), an
emergent WSM is a more versatile playground for study-
ing interaction effects, e.g., topological orders in three
dimension 17–19], generalizations of the standard QED
20, etc.
An emergent WSM is a strongly interacting lattice sys-
tem of spins or electrons, of which the low energy effec-
tive theory is described by an emergent U(1)gauge field
(or some Zmdescendent) coupled to a WSM formed by
emergent fermions. In spin liquid terminology, these are
U(1)(or Zm) spin liquids with spinon Weyl semi-metals.
Unlike in ordinary Weyl semimetals, the emergent Weyl
fermions could naturally have velocity close to that of the
U(1)gauge field, and the gauge coupling strength (fine
structure constant) does not have to be small at a given
energy scale. The possibility of an emergent WSM phase
has been demonstrated in Ref. [17, 21–24]. The emer-
gent WSM phase was further proposed to be the parent
state of topological orders in three dimension [17–19].
While the descendent topologically ordered phases are
stable by the formation of many-body gap, the proper-
ties of the emergent WSM phase itself is largely studied
at the mean-field level. In particular, the dynamical con-
sequences of gauge fluctuations in emergent WSM remain
unexplored.
In this work, we focus on the case with the emergent
U(1) gauge field, also referred to as emergent electro-
magnetic (EM) field. One important notion in studying
WSM phase is the unquantized anomaly, which guaran-
tees the gaplessness of WSM [11, 25–27]. When an EM
field emerges, the dynamical aspect of the anomalies is
also an important piece of information. The unquan-
tized anomaly appears as a Chern-Simons-like action in
3+1D [11, 25–27]. Together with the Maxwell action,
the modified electrodynamics is usually referred to as
Carroll-Field-Jackiw electrodynamics [20]. In the mod-
ified electrodynamics, the physical polarization of prop-
agating photons is different from those in the vacuum.
Another important feature is the anisotropy. In particu-
lar, one of the photon modes becomes soft in a particular
direction [20]. Emergent photons with similar features
were also found in the coupled layers of Laughlin states
[28].
In this article, we study the interplay between the
fermionic degrees of freedom and the modified electro-
dynamics in emergent WSM. The situation under con-
sideration is really a simple, non-Lorentz-symmetric gen-
eralization of textbook quantum electrodynamics (QED),
however with unconventional outcomes. Indeed, we will
show that due to the interaction with the soft photons,
the emergent WSM represents an unconventional quan-
tum liquid.
More specifically, the presence of soft photons sig-
nificantly influences the low-energy properties of the
fermions. There are two major results. First, the fermion
dispersion is strongly dressed by the photons. Namely,
the fermion’s velocity in the soft photon direction is re-
duced to zero under the rernormalization group (RG)
flow. Besides, the system flows to a non-interacting limit
under RG. Second, fermions can spontaneously emit pho-
tons. As a result, the fermions acquire a finite lifetime,
due to the Cherenkov radiation of the soft photons, that
is inversely proportional to the fine structure constant
and the fermion’s energy. The two effects just men-
tioned make the emergent WSM significantly different
from the free WSM or the standard QED. Indeed, over
arXiv:2210.06641v1 [cond-mat.str-el] 13 Oct 2022