
she control them all, he might as well have married the goosegirl for all the good she did him! And she
would cry it wasn’t her fault her brother was mad, and why didn’t he ask her parents what was wrong
with the contract instead of badgering her, and hadn’t she done her duty by him? I heard quite a lot of
this because when the shouting started she would clutch me to her, and when it was over she and I would
often sneak off to the pantry and steal a pot of jam and eat it under the stairs. At the dinner table my
father would quarrel with my older brothers about the cost of Greg’s horses or Seb’s tutors, or what they
should plant in the south reach, or what to do about tenants poaching rabbits. I was glad I was too young
for him to pay much attention to; only sometimes he would take my face in his big hands and look at me
hard, as if he were trying to find out which side of the family I favored. “You’re a sensible girl,” he’d say
hopefully. “You’re a help to your mother, aren’t you?” Well, I tried to be.
Father died suddenly when I was eleven. Things got much quieter then. And just as suddenly, the
lawsuits stopped as well. It was as if the Mad Duke Tremontaine had forgotten all about us.
Then, about a year ago, just when we had begun to stop counting every copper, the letters started
coming again, with their heavy seals. It seemed the lawsuit was back.
My brother Sebastian begged to be allowed to go to the city to study law at University, but Seb was
needed at home; he was much too clever about land and farming and things. Instead Gregory, who was
Lord Talbert now, went to the city to find us new lawyers, and take his place on the Council of Lords. It
was expensive having him there, and we were once again without the revenue from my mother’s portion.
If we didn’t sell the spoons, we were going to have to sell some of my father’s land, and everyone knows
once you start chipping away at your estate, you’re pretty much done for.
And now here was the Mad Duke, actually inviting us to the city to be his guests at Tremontaine House.
My mother looked troubled, but I knew such an invitation could mean only one thing: an end to the
horrible lawsuits, the awful letters. Surely all was forgiven and forgotten. We would go to town and take
our place amongst the nobility there at last, with parties and dancing and music and jewels and clothes—I
threw my arms around my mother’s waist, and hugged her warmly. “Oh, Mama! I knew no one could
stay angry with you forever. I am so happy for you!”
But she pulled away from me. “Don’t be. The entire thing is ridiculous. It’s out of the question.”
“But—don’t you wish to see your brother again? If I hadn’t seen Greg or Seb for twenty years, I’d at
least be curious.”
“I know what Davey’s like.” She twisted the handkerchief in her hand. “He hasn’t changed a bit. He
fought with our parents all the time…” She stroked my hair. “You don’t know how lucky you are, Kitty,
to have such a kind and loving family. I know Papa was sometimes harsh, but he did care for all of us.
And you and I have always been the best of friends, haven’t we?”
I nodded.
“Davey and I were like that. Friends. Good friends, together against the world. We made up games, and
protected each other. But people grow up, don’t they? You can’t stay a child forever. When my parents
chose a husband for me, we were—he was—well, Davey just didn’t understand that things must
change.”
“He hated Papa, didn’t he?”
“He was only a boy; what did he know? Charles was a neighbor, not some stranger. My parents trusted