
Perturbative gadgets for gate-based quantum computing:
Non-recursive constructions without subspace restrictions
Simon Cichy,
1, 2
Paul K. Faehrmann,
1, ∗
Sumeet Khatri,
1
and Jens Eisert
1, 3, 4
1
Dahlem Center for Complex Quantum Systems, Freie Universität Berlin, 14195 Berlin, Germany
2
Institute for Theoretical Physics, ETH Zürich, 8093 Zürich, Switzerland
3
Helmholtz-Zentrum Berlin für Materialien und Energie, Hahn-Meitner-Platz 1, 14109 Berlin, Germany
4
Fraunhofer Heinrich Hertz Institute, 10587 Berlin, Germany
(Dated: August 28, 2024)
Perturbative gadgets are a tool to encode part of a Hamiltonian, usually the low-energy subspace, into a
different Hamiltonian with favorable properties, for instance, reduced locality. Many constructions of perturbative
gadgets have been proposed over the years. Still, all of them are restricted in some ways: Either they apply to
some specific classes of Hamiltonians, they involve recursion to reduce locality, or they are limited to studying
time evolution under the gadget Hamiltonian, e.g., in the context of adiabatic quantum computing, and thus
involve subspace restrictions. In this work, we fill the gap by introducing a versatile universal, non-recursive,
non-adiabatic perturbative gadget construction without subspace restrictions, that encodes an arbitrary many-body
Hamiltonian into the low-energy subspace of a three-body Hamiltonian and is therefore applicable to gate-based
quantum computing. Our construction requires
𝑟 𝑘
additional qubits for a
𝑘
-body Hamiltonian comprising
𝑟
terms.
Besides a specific gadget construction, we also provide a recipe for constructing similar gadgets, which can be
tailored to different properties, which we discuss.
I. INTRODUCTION
The study of many-body Hamiltonians is a well-researched
field in condensed-matter physics and quantum information
theory. While the presence of Hamiltonian terms acting on
many qubits simultaneously can result in exciting phenomena,
in many situations, it also carries additional difficulties. Be it
due to the hardness of generating them experimentally or other
limitations, local Hamiltonians are usually simpler to deal with.
Born in the context of complexity theory for proving the
QMA-completeness of the local Hamiltonian problem [
1
,
2
],
a problem located at the interface of the theory of quantum
many-body physics and Hamiltonian complexity, so-called
perturbative gadgets can be used to reduce the locality of a
given many-body Hamiltonian. This is done by embedding
it in the low-energy subspace of a tailored, local, i.e., few-
body, Hamiltonian acting on a larger Hilbert space [
3
,
4
].
Among the best-known constructions is the subdivision gadget
proposed by Oliveira and Terhal [
4
]. It employs mediator
qubits to halve the support of a given Hamiltonian term and
can be recursively applied to construct an at best three-body
Hamiltonian mimicking the original
𝑘
-body Hamiltonian. As is
typical for perturbative gadgets, such a procedure, unfortunately,
leads to an exponential increase of the interaction strengths
required for the gadget Hamiltonian to accurately mimic the
low-energy subspace of the original Hamiltonian.
A different gadget, proposed by Jordan and Farhi [
5
], can
avoid the need for recursion and offers a direct reduction from
𝑘
-body to two-body Hamiltonians, albeit with an exponential
suppression of energies. However, their direct construction is
only applicable when one can restrict the evolution of chosen
initial states to predefined subspaces of the Hilbert space, as
can be done in adiabatic quantum computing, where commuta-
∗SC and PKF have contributed equally.
tion relations guarantee the system remains in the initialized
subspace.
Since such a limitation restricts the applicability of this direct
𝑘
-to-two-local gadget, the question arises whether there exists a
direct, non-recursive
𝑘
-to-
𝑘′
-local gadget without such restric-
tions and whether such a gadget could have any applications
besides being a tool for proving complexity theoretic results.
After all, perturbative gadgets have so far mostly found their
application in proving hardness results for the general local
Hamiltonian problem [
3
,
4
] or certain classes of Hamiltoni-
ans [6–10] equipped with further constraints and properties.
In this work, we address these questions by proposing a
direct
𝑘
-to-three-local gadget without the need for subspace
restrictions, that is inspired by Ref. [
5
] but that avoids initial-
ization and commutation properties from adiabatic quantum
computing to achieve the same locality reduction as the re-
peated subdivision procedure [
4
], without requiring recursive
applications.
As expected of gadget constructions [
11
], our construction
is also not free from unfavorable energy scalings, but we still
explore the use of such a gadget within gate-based quantum
computing and, in particular, as a method for reducing the
locality of the cost function in variational quantum algorithms,
a setting that does not comply with the “adiabatic” restriction,
or the grouping of measurement terms.
While most likely unfavorable for situations where the lo-
cality of a Hamiltonian scales with the system size, there are
plenty of situations where the locality is constant but still high
enough to cause problems. Examples include measurement
noise scaling with the locality of the measurement operator in-
fluencing noise-induced barren plateaus [
12
] or time evolution
and quantum phase estimation for restricted hardware settings.
The proposed methods do not rely on subspace restrictions and
can thus be implemented in gate-based quantum computing. By
providing a more general recipe for constructing perturbative
gadgets with similar performance guarantees and suggesting
plausible heuristics, we hope to start a discussion about how
arXiv:2210.03099v4 [quant-ph] 27 Aug 2024