Parametrized quantum circuit for weight-adjustable quantum loop gas
Rong-Yang Sun,1, 2 Tomonori Shirakawa,1, 2 and Seiji Yunoki1, 2, 3, 4
1Computational Materials Science Research Team,
RIKEN Center for Computational Science (R-CCS), Kobe, Hyogo, 650-0047, Japan
2Quantum Computational Science Research Team,
RIKEN Center for Quantum Computing (RQC), Wako, Saitama, 351-0198, Japan
3Computational Quantum Matter Research Team,
RIKEN Center for Emergent Matter Science (CEMS), Wako, Saitama 351-0198, Japan
4Computational Condensed Matter Physics Laboratory,
RIKEN Cluster for Pioneering Research (CPR), Saitama 351-0198, Japan
(Dated: January 30, 2023)
Motivated by the recent success of realizing the topologically ordered ground state of the exactly
solvable toric code model by a quantum circuit on the real quantum device [K. J. Satzinger et al.,
Science 374, 1237 (2021)], here we propose a parametrized quantum circuit (PQC) with the same
real-device-performable optimal structure to represent quantum loop gas states with adjustably
weighted loop configurations. Combining such a PQC with the variational quantum eigensolver,
we obtain the accurate quantum circuit representation for the toric code model in an external
magnetic field with any field strength, where the system is not exactly solvable. The topological
quantum phase transition in this system is further observed in the optimized circuits by measuring
the magnetization and topological entanglement entropy.
Introduction.— The topologically ordered state, a new
category of exotic quantum states of matter, has continu-
ously attracted research interest in recent decades [1–3].
Many novel properties that emerge from it include the
degenerate ground state with long-range quantum en-
tanglement and the anyonic-type excitations, which are
also deemed essential for the development of quantum
computing [4, 5]. However, because of the existence of
the long-range quantum entanglement, it is challenging
to investigate the topologically ordered state. Except
for rare elaborately constructed exactly solvable models,
such as Kitaev’s toric code model [4] and Wen’s plaque-
tte model [6], it is difficult to verify whether a topologi-
cally ordered phase exists in a certain microscopic quan-
tum many-body Hamiltonian and to identify its nature,
a famous example being the spin-1/2 antiferromagnetic
Heisenberg model on the kagome lattice [7–10].
On the other hand, rapidly developed synthetic con-
trollable quantum platforms, both in circuit-based quan-
tum computers [11, 12] and analog quantum simula-
tors [13–15], offer a new way to explore these long-range-
entangled states. These controllable quantum systems
have an intrinsic quantum entangled nature and thus are
expected to be able to handle another quantum entangled
system relatively easier. Recently, this expectation has
been partially realized. One can use the optimal quan-
tum resource to realize the ground state of the toric code
model and accurately probe its properties [16], demon-
strating a huge potential for utilizing quantum computers
to study topologically ordered states.
Many algorithms have been proposed to efficiently use
the quantum resource for solving a generic non-exactly
solvable quantum many-body problem. Among them,
the most promising one, which is considered to be realiz-
able on current noisy-intermediate scale quantum (NISQ)
devices [17, 18], is the variational quantum eigensolver
(VQE) [19–21]. The VQE adopts a parametrized quan-
tum circuit (PQC) as the ansatz state. This PQC ansatz
is evaluated on a quantum computer, while its parame-
ters are optimized by a classical optimizer. Despite con-
siderable efforts, the scalable realization of the VQE on
NISQ devices is still under extensive research. This is be-
cause proper PQC ansatze, which can faithfully describe
the ground state of a given quantum many-body Hamil-
tonian and yet can be performed accurately enough on
real devices, are still missing, especially when the sys-
tem is close to a phase transition point (for example, see
Ref. [22]).
In this paper, we address this issue by proposing
a PQC, which has adequate expressibility towards the
ground state of a non-exactly solvable correlated Hamil-
tonian and at the same time can be faithfully evalu-
ated on NISQ devices. We encode a quantum loop gas
state with adjustably weighted loop configurations into a
quantum circuit with the optimal circuit depth. The ad-
justable weights are controlled by circuit parameters. Us-
ing such a single PQC, we precisely reproduce the ground
state with an energy accuracy better than the order of
10−2for the toric code model in an external magnetic
field, thus in both topologically ordered and ferromag-
netically ordered phases, by VQE calculations.
Toric code model in a magnetic field.— The toric code
model [4] is defined by qubits located on the bond centers
of a Lx×Lysquare lattice with Nbonds, and is given
by the following Hamiltonian:
HTC =−X
s
As−X
p
Bp,(1)
where As=Qi∈sσz
iand Bp=Qi∈pσx
i. Here, σz
i(σx
i) is
the Pauli Z(X) operator of qubit ilocated on the i-th
arXiv:2210.14662v2 [quant-ph] 27 Jan 2023