their subtlety. Such are quite in keeping with the psychology and languages of the race we are studying.
Yet, throughout America, as in most other parts of the world, the teaching of religious tenets was twofold, the
one popular, the other for the initiated, an esoteric and an exoteric doctrine. A difference in dialect was
assiduously cultivated, a sort of “sacred language" being employed to conceal while it conveyed the mysteries
of faith. Some linguists think that these dialects are archaic forms of the language, the memory of which was
retained in ceremonial observances; others maintain that they were simply affectations of expression, and
form a sort of slang, based on the every day language, and current among the initiated. I am inclined to the
latter as the correct opinion, in many cases.
Whichever it was, such a sacred dialect is found in almost all tribes. There are fragments of it from the
cultivated races of Mexico, Yucatan and Peru; and at the other end of the scale we may instance the Guaymis,
of Darien, naked savages, but whose “chiefs of the law,” we are told, taught “the doctrines of their religion in
a peculiar idiom, invented for the purpose, and very different from the common language.”[1]
[Footnote 1: Franco, Noticia de los Indios Guaymies y de sus Costumbres, p. 20, in Pinart, Coleccion de
Linguistica y Etnografia Americana. Tom. iv.]
This becomes an added difficulty in the analysis of myths, as not only were the names of the divinities and of
localities expressed in terms in the highest degree metaphorical, but they were at times obscured by an
affected pronunciation, devised to conceal their exact derivation.
The native tribes of this Continent had many myths, and among them there was one which was so prominent,
and recurred with such strangely similar features in localities widely asunder, that it has for years attracted my
attention, and I have been led to present it as it occurs among several nations far apart, both geographically
and in point of culture. This myth is that of the national hero, their mythical civilizer and teacher of the tribe,
who, at the same time, was often identified with the supreme deity and the creator of the world. It is the
fundamental myth of a very large number of American tribes, and on its recognition and interpretation
depends the correct understanding of most of their mythology and religious life.
The outlines of this legend are to the effect that in some exceedingly remote time this divinity took an active
part in creating the world and in fitting it to be the abode of man, and may himself have formed or called forth
the race. At any rate, his interest in its advancement was such that he personally appeared among the ancestors
of the nation, and taught them the useful arts, gave them the maize or other food plants, initiated them into the
mysteries of their religious rites, framed the laws which governed their social relations, and having thus
started them on the road to self development, he left them, not suffering death, but disappearing in some way
from their view. Hence it was nigh universally expected that at some time he would return.
The circumstances attending the birth of these hero−gods have great similarity. As a rule, each is a twin or one
of four brothers born at one birth; very generally at the cost of their mother's life, who is a virgin, or at least
had never been impregnated by mortal man. The hero is apt to come into conflict with his brother, or one of
his brothers, and the long and desperate struggle resulting, which often involved the universe in repeated
destructions, constitutes one of the leading topics of the myth−makers. The duel is not generally—not at all, I
believe, when we can get at the genuine native form of the myth—between a morally good and an evil spirit,
though, undoubtedly, the one is more friendly and favorable to the welfare of man than the other.
The better of the two, the true hero−god, is in the end triumphant, though the national temperament
represented this variously. At any rate, his people are not deserted by him, and though absent, and perhaps for
a while driven away by his potent adversary, he is sure to come back some time or other.
American Hero−Myths
CHAPTER I. INTRODUCTORY. 7