And Jarles now looked around him in bewilderment. He had expected to be silenced almost at
once. His sole object had been to say as much as he could, or rather to let his anger say whatever it
wanted to in its brief moment of freedom.
But the blow did not fall. No priest made a move toward him, or acted as if anything out of the
ordinary were happening. And his unquenched anger continued to speak for him.
“Commoners of Megatheopolis, what I am going to ask you to do is hard. Harder than work in
the mines, though I won’t ask you to lift a finger. I want you to listen to what I say, to weigh my
words for truth, to make a judgment as to the worth of what I tell you, and then to act on that
judgment. You hardly know what all that means, but you must try to do it, nevertheless! To weigh
my words for truth? That’s to see how they square with what you’ve seen happen in your private
lives—not what you’ve been told. To make a judgment? That’s to decide whether or not you want
something, after you’ve learned what it is. I know the priests have told you all that is wrong. Forget
the priests! Forget I wear the scarlet robe. And listen, listen!”
Now surely the blow must fall! They wouldn’t let him say any more! Involuntarily he looked up
at the form of the Great God. But that serene idol was taking no more notice of what was happening
in the square than a human being might take of a swarming of ants around a bit of sugar.
“You all know the story of the Golden Age,” he was already saying, his voice now richly vibrant
with secrets to unfold. “You hear it every time you go to the Cathedral. How the Great God gave
divine powers to all men, so that they lived as in paradise, without toil or sorrow. How men grew
restless and dissatisfied, wanting still more, and sinned in all manner of ways, and lived in vice and
lechery. How the Great God in mercy restrained his anger, hoping that they would reform. How, in
their evil pride, they finally sought to storm heaven itself and all its stars. Then, as the priests never
weary of telling you, the Great God rose up in his wisdom and wrath, and winnowed out the few
men who had not sinned against him and were still obedient to his holy laws. Them he made into
his Hierarchy and gave them supernatural powers even greater than before. The rest—the sinful
ones—he cast down and ground into the dust, and gave his Hierarchy power over them, so that
those who had not of their own free wills lived virtuously would be made to do so by force! Then
he further decreed that his Hierarchy select from each generation of men the naturally virtuous to
be priests, and reject the rest, to toil in blissful ignorance under the gentle but inflexible guidance of
the priests, who are the Hierarchy.”
He paused, looked searchingly into the staring faces.
“That much, all of you know by heart. But not one of you dreams of the truth behind the story!”
Without anger whipping him on, Jarles might have stopped then and there and walked into the
Sanctuary and down into the crypts, so stupid and uncomprehending were the commoners’
reactions, so obviously did they misinterpret every word. At first they had seemed only shocked
and bewildered, though attentive as always. Then—when he had called upon them to think and
judge—they had looked vaguely apprehensive, as if all this rigmarole were merely the introduction
to some assignment of physical labor, literally harder than work in the mines. The story of the
Golden Age had lulled them. It was something familiar. His last sentence had shattered the lull and
brought them again into that state of stupid, anxious gawking.
But what else could he expect? If he could only manage to plant the seeds of questioning in just
one commoner!
“There was a Golden Age. That much is true. Though as far as I know there was plenty of toil
and sorrow in it. But at least all men had a little freedom and were getting more. The getting of it
meant trouble—lots of it—and at one point the scientists became frightened and ... but you don’t
even know what a scientist is, do you? Any more than you know what a doctor is, or a lawyer, or a