cormorants are nesting. I want to see how fast you can do it."
"Melissa--" said Little Miss uneasily.
"Shh, Amanda. I want Andrew to go out there. Maybe he can find some
cormorant eggs and bring them back to show us."
"It would not be good to disturb the nest, Miss, " said Andrew gently.
"I said I wanted you to go out there."
"Melissa--" Little Miss said again, more sharply.
But Miss was insistent. It was an order. Andrew felt the preliminary
signs of contradictory potentials building up: a faint trembling in his
fingertips, a barely perceptible sense of vertigo. Orders were to be obeyed:
that was the Second Law. Miss could order him to swim to China this minute,
and Andrew would do it without hesitation if no other considerations were
involved. But he was here to protect the girls. What would happen if something
unexpected befell them while he was out by the cormorant rock? A sudden
menacing wave, a rockslide, even an earthquake--earthquakes weren't everyday
occurrences here, but they certainly could happen at any time
It was a pure First Law issue.
"I am sorry, Miss. With no adults here to guard you, I am unable to
leave you unattended long enough to swim to that rock and back. If Sir or
Ma'am were present, that would be a different matter, but as it is--"
"Don't you recognize an order when you hear one? I want you to swim out
there, Andrew."
"As I have explained, Miss--"
"You don't have to worry about us. It's not as though I'm a child,
Andrew. What do you think, that some sort of terrible ogre is going to come
down the beach and gobble us up while you're in the water? I can look after
myself, thank you, and I'll take care of Amanda too if I have to."
Little Miss said, "You aren't being fair to him, Melissa. He's got his
orders from Daddy."
"And now he has his orders from me." Miss gestured peremptorily. "Swim
out to the cormorant rock, Andrew. Go ahead. Now, Andrew."
Andrew felt himself growing a little warm, and ordered his circuitry to
make the necessary homeostatic correction.
"The First Law--" he began.
"What a bore you are! You and your First Law both!" cried Melissa.
"Can't you forget the First Law once in a while? But no, no, you can't do
that, can you? You've got those silly laws wired into you and there's no
getting around them. You're nothing but a dumb machine."
"Melissa!" Little Miss said indignantly.
"Yes, that is true," said Andrew. "As you correctly state, I am nothing
but a dumb machine. And therefore I have no ability to countermand your
father's order concerning your safety on the beach." He bowed slightly in
Melissa's direction. "I deeply regret this, Miss."
Little Miss said, "If you want to see Andrew swim so much, Melissa, why
don't you just have him wade into the surf and do some swimming right close to
shore? There wouldn't be any harm in that, would there?"
"It wouldn't be the same thing," Miss said, pouting. "Not at all."
But, Andrew reflected, perhaps that would satisfy her. He disliked being
the focus of so much disharmony.
"Let me show you," he said.
He waded in. The heavy foam-flecked surf thundered up violently around
his knees, but Andrew was able easily to adjust his gyroscopic stabilizers as
the force of the breaking waves assailed him. The rough, sharp rocks that were
scattered allover the sea floor meant nothing to his metallic treads. His
sensors told him that the temperature of the water was well below human
comfort tolerance, but that, too, was irrelevant to him.
Four or five meters out, the water was deep enough so that Andrew could